Pathogen Populations Evolve to Greater Race Complexity in Agricultural Systems – Evidence from Analysis of Rhynchosporium secalis Virulence Data

Abstract

Fitness cost associated with pathogens carrying unnecessary virulence alleles is the fundamental assumption for preventing the emergence of complex races in plant pathogen populations but this hypothesis has rarely been tested empirically on a temporal and spatial scale which is sufficient to distinguish evolutionary signals from experimental error. We analyzed virulence characteristics of ∼1000 isolates of the barley pathogen Rhynchosporium secalis collected from different parts of the United Kingdom between 1984 and 2005. We found a gradual increase in race complexity over time with a significant correlation between sampling date and race complexity of the pathogen (r20 = 0.71, p = 0.0002) and an average loss of 0.1 avirulence alleles (corresponding to an average gain of 0.1 virulence alleles) each year. We also found a positive and significant correlation between barley cultivar diversity and R. secalis virulence variation. The conditions assumed to favour complex races were not present in the United Kingdom and we hypothesize that the increase in race complexity is attributable to the combination of natural selection and genetic drift. Host resistance selects for corresponding virulence alleles to fixation or dominant frequency. Because of the weak fitness penalty of carrying the unnecessary virulence alleles, genetic drift associated with other evolutionary forces such as hitch-hiking maintains the frequency of the dominant virulence alleles even after the corresponding resistance factors cease to be used.

The Jack of All Trades Is Master of None: A Pathogen's Ability to Infect a Greater Number of Host Genotypes Comes at a Cost of Delayed Reproduction

“…As observed in other agricultural pathogens (Zhan et al. ; Zhan and McDonald ), results for P. coronata demonstrate considerable variation in virulence level among individuals, and in the frequencies of specific virulence alleles over the geographic range (this report; Carson , ). We posit that historical breeding practices and landscape level demographic processes generate selection for increased host genotype range that outweigh the constraints imposed by costs at smaller spatial or temporal scales.…”

Association between Virulence and Triazole Tolerance in the Phytopathogenic Fungus Mycosphaerella graminicola

“…It suggests that one unforeseen consequence of widespread deployment of quantitatively resistant cultivars or intensive application of synthetic antimicrobials might be selection for a higher basal level of antimicrobial resistance and enhanced virulence in pathogen populations, which would pose a greater threat to agricultural production. In this case, more dynamic disease management programs that incorporate more rapid spatial and temporal turnover of host resistance or synthetic antimicrobials may be important for sustainable disease control [74]. More rapid spatial and temporal turnover of host resistance or antimicrobials is expected to generate fluctuating selection against pathogens that could prevent the emergence of pathogen individuals and populations with higher virulence and antimicrobial resistance.…”

An assay for quantitative virulence in Rhynchosporium commune reveals an association between effector genotype and virulence

“…Results from other studies suggested that the ability of R. commune to adapt in response to changes in host resistance or host diversity is high. The pathogen was shown to evolve simpler races when host diversity is low (Jackson & Webster, 1976b) or more complex races when host diversity is high (Zhang et al, 1992;Zhan et al, 2012). Furthermore, it was shown to quickly overcome major resistance genes deployed in host cultivars (Xi et al, 2002).…”