Photorespiration is of great interest because of its relationship to plant productivity. It has been estimated that in C3 plants, the process of photorespiration oxidizes up to 50% of the newly synthesized photosynthetic products, whereas in C4 plants, photorespiration is either not present or occurs in much reduced amounts (20). In addition to the lack of apparent photorespiration and significantly greater net assimilation rate, C4 plants also possess several other structural and physiological features which distinguish them from C3 plants. These include: a different chloroplast ultrastructure, reduced discrimination of 13C relative to '2C, higher temperature optimum for photosynthesis, higher light saturation point, and significantly lower transpiration to photosynthesis ratios (13,19).One of the most interesting features of C4 plants is that virtually all of them have a characteristic leaf anatomy consisting of at least two chloroplast-containing cell layers radially arranged around the vascular bundles. This concentric arrangement of chlorenchyma cells in C4 plant leaves has been called "Kranz" anatomy (13), and many structure-function postulations have been made concerning the importance of Kranz anatomy to the over-all physiology of C4 plants. There is general agreement that operation of the complete cycle of C4 reactions is closely associated with, if not dependent upon, possession of Kranz anatomy by C4 plants. This is particularly true for the apparent lack of photorespiration. As envisioned, the concentric arrangement of chloroplast-containing cells in C4 plants acts either to inhibit photorespiratory CO2 loss by high CO2 concentrations in the bundle sheath cells, or to promote refixation of evolved CO2 as it diffuses outwardly through the mesophyll cells. A discussion and models for such structure-function relationships in C4 plants have recently been given (13).Regardless of the exact mechanism, most reports agree on the singular importance of Kranz anatomy in minimizing or eliminating detectable CO2 evolution in the light by C4 plants (1,3,7,15,16 (10), and photorespiratory responses in senescing Portulaca oleracea leaves which are virtually indistinguishable from those of mature C3 plant leaves (9). In spite of these examples, operation of the C4 pathway, particularly the lack of detectable photorespiration in C4 plants, is still thought by many to be dependent on an intact Kranz anatomy.
MATERIALS AND METHODSIn the present experiments, P. oleracea L. stem tissue cultures, grown under a controlled light (about 80 ,einsteins m-2 sec-') and temperature regime (20 C) were used in all experiments. Cultures, conditions, and media were otherwise as reported by Laetsch and Kortschak (14). These tissues were similar to mature P. oleracea leaves on the basis of cell ultrastructure and 14C02 labeling patterns (10, unpublished observations). In addition, leaves and tissue cultures of a C3 plant, Streptanthus tortuosus, were used to enable comparison of photorespiratory activity in C3 plant tissues to ...