Patient-Centered Cancer Treatment Planning: Improving the Quality of Oncology Care. Summary of an Institute of Medicine Workshop

Abstract

The Institute of Medicine's National Cancer Policy Forum recently convened a workshop on patient-centered cancer treatment planning, with the aim of raising awareness about this important but often overlooked aspect of cancer treatment. A primary goal of patientcentered treatment planning is to engage patients and their families in meaningful, thorough interactions with their health care providers to develop an accurate, wellconceived treatment plan, using all available medical information appropriately while also considering the medical, social, and cultural needs and desires of the patient and family. A cancer treatment plan can be shared among the patient, family, and care team in order to facilitate care coordination and provide a roadmap to help patients navigate the path of cancer treatment. There are numerous obstacles to achieving patient-centered cancer treatment planning in practice. Some of these challenges stem from the patient and include patients' lack of assertiveness, health literacy, and numeracy, and their emotional state and concurrent illnesses. Others are a result of physician limitations, such as a lack of time to explain complex information and a lack of tools to facilitate treatment planning, as well as insensitivity to patients' informational, cultural, and emotional needs. Potential solutions to address these obstacles include better training of health care providers and patients in optimal communication and shared decision making, and greater use of support services and tools such as patient navigation and electronic health records. Other options include greater use of quality metrics and reimbursement for the time it takes to develop, discuss, and document a treatment plan. The Oncologist 2011;16:1800 -1805

How Can We Best Respect Patient Autonomy in Breast Cancer Treatment Decisions?

“…Systemic barriers to physician participation in shared decision-making with patients, such as limited time with patients, will not be easily surmountable. That said, physician-directed interventions to support shared decision-making in clinical practice are needed [110]. Development of new decision support tools will need to strongly consider existing physician- and system-level barriers to their use in clinical practice.…”

Value Based Care and Patient-Centered Care: Divergent or Complementary?

“…These have included, but are not limited to, patient education programs, centers for shared decision-making, support groups, and decision aids [26]. However, the practical implementation of such strategies is challenging, and the usage and provision of such patientcentered resources do not integrate clearly with traditional approaches to value-based care.…”

Culturally Competent Care for Sexual and Gender Minority Patients at National Cancer Institute-Designated Comprehensive Cancer Centers

“…11,12 Central to patient-centered care is a meaningful engagement with patients and their families by healthcare providers to coordinate treatment and survivorship plans that are considerate of an individual's medical, social, and cultural needs. 13 To facilitate meaningful engagement, it is essential that patients are provided with opportunities to disclose their sexual orientation and gender identity (SOGI) in ways that are considerate and respectful. Systematic changes to patient education and support, provider workforce development, quality improvement, and institutional policies to reduce cancer health disparities among SGM populations have been recommended by the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO).…”