Patient–provider race-concordance: does it matter in improving minority patients’ health outcomes?

Abstract

Objective To understand if patient–provider race-concordance is associated with improved health outcomes for minorities. Design A comprehensive review of published research literature (1980–2008) using MEDLINE, HealthSTAR, and CINAHL databases were conducted. Studies were included if they had at least one research question examining the effect of patient–provider race-concordance on minority patients’ health outcomes and pertained to minorities in the USA. The database search and data analysis were each independently conducted by two authors. The review was limited to data analysis in tabular and text format. A meta-analysis was not possible due to the discrepancy in methods and outcomes across studies. Results Twenty-seven studies met the inclusion criteria. Combined, the studies were based on data from 56,276 patients and only 1756 providers. Whites/Caucasians (37.6%) and Blacks/African Americans (31.5%), followed by Hispanics/Latinos (13.3%), and Asians/Pacific Islanders (4.3%) comprised the majority of the patient sample. The median sample of providers was only 16 for African Americans, 10 for Asians and two for Hispanics. The review presented mixed results. Of the 27 studies, patient–provider race-concordance was associated with positive health outcomes for minorities in only nine studies (33%), while eight studies (30%) found no association of race-concordance with the outcomes studied and 10 (37%) presented mixed findings. Analysis suggested that having a provider of same race did not improve ‘receipt of services’ for minorities. No clear pattern of findings emerged in the domains of healthcare utilization, patient–provider communication, preference, satisfaction, or perception of respect. Conclusions There is inconclusive evidence to support that patient–provider race-concordance is associated with positive health outcomes for minorities. Studies were limited to four racial/ethnic groups and generally employed small samples of minorities. Further research is needed to understand what health outcomes may be more sensitive to cultural proximity between patients and providers, and what patient, provider and setting-level variables may moderate or mediate these outcomes.

Medical Care of Hepatitis B among Asian American Populations: Perspectives from Three Provider Groups

“…[46][47][48] However, there are other means by which physicians can demonstrate respect or trust without requiring race or ethnic concordance, including increasing familiarity with patients and understanding their cultural values and beliefs. 49,50 Finally, CAM presented itself as a topic that physicians leveraged to demonstrate cultural sensitivity. Physicians' and patients' attitudes about CAM reflected cultural differences that affected care.…”

Provider Perceptions of Parent Health Literacy and Effect on Asthma Treatment Recommendations and Instructions

“…Other studies of patient-provider racial concordance report mixed results. 12 The health literacy measures used in this study have limitations. The TOFHLA measures reading comprehension and numeracy, while the REALM assesses word recognition and pronunciation.…”

“…10 Two suggested sources of disparities in patient outcomes have been the provider attitudes that impact communication and interaction with the patient 11 and racial concordance between providers and patients. 12 Patients can address racial concordance in their choice of a provider, whereas the providers can address communication and interaction issues.…”

Gender Differences in Medical Advice and Health Behavior of Obese African Americans With and Without Type 2 Diabetes

“…While some studies have found same-race/ethnicity dyads to have more effective communication, others reported no statistically significant differences between same-and mixed-ethnicity dyads. Meghani et al (2009) reviewed patient-provider, race concordance and reported that of the 27 studies approximately one-third were Caucasian, one-third were African American, and 13% were Hispanic. The authors found patient provider race-concordance was associated with positive health outcomes for minorities in nine studies, while eight studies found no association of race-concordance with the outcomes studied and 10 presented mixed findings.…”