Patient-provider relationships in China: A qualitative study on the perspectives of healthcare students and junior professionals

Abstract

Background Mistrust and conflicts in patient-provider relationships (PPR) have become prevalent in China. The frequency of verbal and physical violence against healthcare workers has been increasing, but few interventions seem to be effective. Limited prior research has focused on the perspectives of healthcare professionals in training. This paper aimed to understand their viewpoints and conceptualize potentially actionable areas for future policy interventions. Methods We analyzed de-identified training registration data of a convenience sample of 151 healthcare students and 38 junior professionals from 20 provinces in China. One open-ended question in the registration form asked the participant to comment on PPRs in China. We used qualitative thematic coding to analyze the narrative data. All answers were categorized into three overarching frames: patients, providers, and external agencies/regulations. Frequently mentioned themes in each frame were evaluated to generate an overall theoretical framework. Findings Although fewer than 25% indicated that current PPRs are "good" or acceptable, 98% of respondents were optimistic about the future improvement of these relationships. The leading factors of PPRs mentioned as patient-relevant were eroding trust in the physician, unrealistic expectations, and ineffective communication. The provider-relevant themes highlighted were poor service quality, ineffective communication, and heavy workload. Leading themes relevant to external agencies or regulations were dysfunctional administration system, negative media reports, and disparity in healthcare resource distribution.

Intern nursing students’ perceived barriers to providing end-of-life care for dying cancer patients in a death taboo cultural context: A qualitative study

“…Over the past decade in mainland China, the nurse–patient relationship has become toxic under increasing violence and abuse events from the patients and/or their family members upon the nurses. 38 A variety of reasons are to blame, namely a lack of oversight and law enforcement, media misrepresentation, and an imbalanced distribution of healthcare resources. 39 The toxic relationship has been universally shared in the health system, promoting a sense of negativity and disappointment among healthcare professionals including interns.…”

Two cities, two stages in transforming society—a mixed methods study comparing doctors’ adoption of mobile apps for communication with patients in Hangzhou and Yancheng, China

“…Thematic content analyses, which have been used to conduct explorative studies, are ideal for studying doctor-patient communication ( 18 ), which is replete with privacies and personal perceptions ( 19 ). Du and colleagues also used the qualitative method to explore this complex relationship ( 20 ).…”

Doctors’ Personal Preference and Adoption of Mobile Apps to Communicate with Patients in China: Qualitative Study

“…Despite different findings and conclusions, these studies were based on an implicit assumption that these doctors have full control of their choices, which means that doctors have the freedom to decide how to spend their spare time at their own will. However, in China, this assumption warrants scrutiny due to the well-known issue of excessive workload faced by health care professionals, leaving them with limited leisure time after extended hours [ 16 ].…”