Patient support for tuberculosis patients in low-incidence countries: A systematic review

Abstract

BackgroundPatient support during tuberculosis treatment is expected to be more often available and more customized in low tuberculosis incidence, high-resource settings than in lower-resource settings. The aim of this systematic review is to provide an overview of tuberculosis patient support interventions implemented in low-incidence countries and an evaluation of their effects on treatment-related outcomes as well as their acceptability by patients and providers.MethodsPubMed, Social Science Citation Index and Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health and Literature were searched for the period 01.2006–05.2016 on publications describing tuberculosis patient support interventions in low-incidence countries (<20 patients per 100,000 population).ResultsThrough our search strategy, 1875 unique publications were identified. Forty publications were included: 17 evaluated patient support quantitatively, 9 qualitatively and 14 only described the patient support. Nineteen publications assessed treatment supervision options only, 21 assessed (combinations of) treatment supervision, socio-economic, psycho-emotional, health-educational and other support. Of eight studies quantitatively evaluating the effects of support with a control group, four showed positive effects: two out of three that used combinations of patient support and two out of five that compared treatment supervision options. Heterogeneity of interventions precluded pooling of results. Qualitative and descriptive studies showed that patients appreciated individualized support including treatment supervision, psycho-emotional and socio-economic support; and digital health interventions.ConclusionOur review shows that a variety of patient support interventions is implemented in low-incidence countries. Although only a few interventions were evaluated quantitatively, we identified potential best practices. The scarcity of evidence on effectiveness, however, indicates the need for further research to evaluate potential best practices.

User-experience and patient satisfaction with quality of tuberculosis care in India: A mixed-methods literature review

“…The common themes demonstrate that these aspects of quality of TB care may be important for users globally in a variety of contexts. This review also re-iterated findings in these studies and previous literature reviews on patients’ appreciation of an individualized and flexible DOTS approach to enhance convenience and patient-centered care [121], [122], [123], [124], [125]. Additional themes in these studies that did not play a major role in this review included patient involvement or autonomy in decision-making [110], general conditions of facilities (i.e.…”

“…The schedule should also be dynamically adaptable to maintain continuity of care during life events and migration. The scale-up and institutionalization of effective digital innovations, such as 99DOTS and videoDOTS, may also promote the user-friendliness of DOTS [123,149,150].…”

Understanding illness perception in pulmonary tuberculosis patients: One step towards patient-centered care

“…A small number of participants denied having TB and ascribed it to bad luck or chance. Educating patients and raising awareness in the community are key components of the END TB Strategy by the WHO; however, such patient-centered support programs are limited, indicating that further research will be needed to identify and verify effective and efficient support interventions for TB patients[23].…”

Nursing actions promoting adherence to tuberculosis treatment: scoping review

“…This was the category with the highest density of mentions on the topic presented in the studies. Studies (16)(17)(18)(66)(67) report that over the last ten years, even in different contexts, the success of treatment is consistent with nursing care capable of impacting the conditions related to treatment dropout, of expanding support for the person affected by the disease and ensure treatment maintenance.…”