Patriarchal Binary Oppositions in Narrative Texts Included in English Textbook for Senior High School in Indonesia

Abstract

Patriarchal binary oppositions, which place men and women in dichotomies that marginalised women, can be reproduced through texts, including textbooks. The present study traces these binary oppositions represented in the narrative texts in English textbooks for grade ten High School. Adopting the interactive model of qualitative data analysis from Miles, Huberman, and Saldaña ( 2014), the present study took Kate Millet's feminist perspective to closely analyse the male and female characterisations characters in the three narrative texts included in the book. It was revealed that most male characters in the narrative texts were given stereotypical male characterisations, such as strong, brave, rational, ambitious, hardworking, rough, smart, independent, honest, handsome, and careless;. In contrast, the female characters were given stereotypical feminine traits such as weak, fearful, irrational, passive, nurturing, articulate, stupid, dependent, untrustworthy, beautiful, and caring. However, there have been efforts to deconstruct gender-binary by inserting some on-stereotypical characterisations both the male and female characters in these texts. This implies that while the textbooks still maintain a certain degree of marginalisation toward women, deconstruction of gendered-binary opposition has started to be pioneered by English textbooks. Hopefully, it will be improved in the next production of English textbooks.

A Mouse’s Courage: The Characterizations of the Boy in Roald Dahl's the Witches

“…The Boy made plan and the execution was successful due to his good timing. The ability to follow a plan thoroughly indicates a smart person (Blangsinga et al, 2021;Dewi et al, 2021).…”

The Characterization of Hua Mulan in Disney’s 2020 Live-Action Mulan

“…Mulan's innocence and grace as she poured tea into a cup were also praised by Madam Matchmaker. Moreover, Mulan, who was trained to be elegant, is also related to the figure of the Princess in the story of Issumboshi, who is trained to be beautiful and cultured (Blangsinga et al, 2021). In this case, Mulan was carrying out her obligation as a daughter to bring honor to her family by preparing herself to be a good wife in the matchmaker's place (Sulistia, 2016).…”

The Representation of Sisterhood in Susan Glaspell's Trifle: Proxemic and Kinesic Analyses

“…While the female characters are depicted to confirm the feminine stereotype of passivity and solidarity, the male characters are depicted to confirm the masculine stereotype of logical thinking and independence. As pointed by Blangsinga et al (2021), Riskayani, Suwastini, and Wahyuni (2021), and Suwastini, Suprianti, and Fitrianti (2018, narrative texts can reflect binary oppositions maintained in a patriarchal society while opening a fertile ground for deconstructions of the gendered oppositions that marginalize women Suwastini et al, 2020). In the case of Glaspell's Trifles, proxemics is employed to highlight the stereotypes, drawing attention to how women should stand together in the face of patriarchal male domination.…”