Patron‐client Relationships in Southern Italy*

Abstract

Political clientelism in Southern Italy has shown great persistence and capacity for conditioning the entire Italian political development. Accounting for these characteristics, clientelism is better understood as the product of the incomplete capitalistic rationalization of the Southern economy. Throughout the 19th century in Sicily, the feudo remained the basis of the economic and social structure, while in the continental South the feudal system disintegrated more quickly and widely. The resulting different models of social relationships within the Mezzogiorno, make it meaningful for our purposes to distinguish between two types of clientele, which may be termed clientela mafiosa and Neopolitan clientele. The second part of the article is concerned with the dynamics of the clientelistic system in post‐1945 Southern Italy and more generally with the relationship between clientelism and political development. The transition from the clientelism of the notables to political party‐directed patronage is studied both at the local level and in the context of the whole South. It is then argued that clientelism is a very poor tool for political development since it has two effects on the social structure and the political process: these effects will be called disorganic integration and exclusivism.

The Empirics of Social Capital and Economic Development: A Critical Perspective

“…Furthermore, individual legislators have the ability to personally submit draft bills to the Parliament. Such bills have often a highly clientelistic nature and are subject to discussion only in committee (Sartori, 1976, Di Palma, 1977, Graziano, 1977. In the light of these arguments, it seems reasonable to consider higher amounts of preference votes as an indicator of low levels of civicness.…”

Political clientelism and the media: southern Europe and Latin America in comparative perspective

“…It is a particularistic and asymmetrical form of social organization, and is typically contrasted with forms of citizenship in which access to resources is based on universalistic criteria and formal equality before the law (Legg, 1975;Graziano, 1973;Leal, 1977;Eisenstadt and Lemarchand, 1980;Mouzelis, 1980;Eisenstadt and Roniger, 1984;Roniger and Günes-Ayata, 1994;Gellner and Waterbury, 1977;Fox, 1994;Charalambis, 1989Charalambis, , 1996Kourvetaris and Dobratz, 1999). Clientelistic relationships have been central to the social and political organization of all seven countries covered here.…”

Temptation in vote-selling: Evidence from a field experiment in the Philippines

“…2013.) Vote-buying also hampers the development of and trust in the political institutions necessary for democratic development and consolidation (Lyne 2007;Stokes 2005;Graziano 1973;Kitschelt et. al.…”