Patterns of empathy as embodied practice in clinical conversation—a musical dimension

Abstract

Cognitive linguistics and conversation analysis (a) converge in the analysis of category bound activities and (b) in viewing thinking and talking as embodied activities. The first aim of this paper is to outline these powerful theories as useful tools for the analysis of enacting empathy. The second aim is to outline these theories as useful tools for the analysis of how empathy is co-enacted in clinical conversation documented in transcripts. Cognitive Linguistics and Conversation Analysis converge in detecting patterns of I-You-relationships with roots in early preverbal embodied protoconversation continuing to more symbolic conversational level. The paper proposes to describe this continuity of empathic conversation in musical metaphors like balance, rhythm and resonance. In a first section transcripts from therapeutic sessions are presented. In a second section linguistic and other research data are presented in order to bring empirical data to this new conception of how empathy can be understood, how it is done and how two participants cooperate to enact empathy. Ideas for further research are outlined.

A Dual Route Model for Regulating Emotions: Comparing Models, Techniques and Biological Mechanisms

“…During sessions, the therapist shows that he/her understands why the patient shows dysfunctional patterns, and explains how they are relative to traumatic childhood experiences Beyond empathic confrontation, an empathic attitude of the therapist can be considered the basis for all therapeutic interventions. Communication research has largely contributed to the description of empathic interventions emphasizing the role of non-verbal aspects such as prosody or physiological synchronization (Wynn and Wynn, 2006;Cameron, 2011;Messina et al, 2013;Buchholz, 2014;Weiste and Peräkylä, 2014;Peräkylä et al, 2015;Buchholz et al, 2017;Voutilainen et al, 2018).…”

“At my core, I am a psychoanalyst, but … ”: An interview with Michael B. Buchholz

“…: Your interest in psychotherapeutic interaction is, I think, very strongly connected to your lifelong interest in music. You have published several studies and coordinated several research projects that connect psychotherapy interaction with musical structures (Breyer, Buchholz, Hamburger, Pfänder, & Schumann, 2017;Buchholz, 2014;Buchholz & Gödde, 2013;Buchholz, Ehmer, Mahlstedt, Pfänder, & Schumann, 2021).…”

Psychodynamic Psychotherapy Process Research: A quick ride through what you should know about process (research)

“…One of the most fascinating results of this type of observing interaction is that certain similarities with preverbal exchange in mother‐infant observation were found (Bullowa ; Meltzoff & Brooks ) even on a psychophysiological level (Ham & Tronick ), while others worked on the musical dimension of conversational features in early and adult interactions (Malloch & Trevarthen ). There is a musical dimension in empathy (Buchholz ).…”