Understanding
the reaction mechanisms, particularly the chiral
induction mode, is critical for the development of new asymmetric
catalytic reactions. Rhodium(III)-catalyzed C–H activation
en route to atroposelective [4 + 2] annulative coupling with α-diazo
β-ketoesters has been realized, affording axially chiral phenanthrenes
in good to excellent enantioselectivity. A combination of experimental
and computational studies revealed a nontraditional stereodivergent–convergent
chiral induction mode. The reaction proceeded with a rhodafluorene
intermediate, followed by competitive, constructive, and stereodivergent
migratory insertions of the two Rh–C(aryl) bonds into the carbene
species to give β-ketoester intermediates. Then, the other Rh–C(aryl)
bond migratorily inserts into the ketone carbonyl group. Following
this stereodetermining carbonyl insertion, an ester-chelated rhodium(III)
alkoxide species bearing two poorly controlled chiral centers and
a well-controlled C(sp2)–C(sp3) chiral
axis is generated. The final product is delivered via stereoconvergent
elimination of a rhodium(III) species with retention of the well-controlled
axial chirality and with loss of the central chirality.