Carbon-hydrogen bonds in organic molecules can be cut to install other chemical groups on the carbon atom, but these reactions have been limited. A catalytic palladium complex opens up fresh opportunities. See Letter p.489
J OA N N A W E N C E L-D E L O R D & F R A N Ç O I S E C O L O B E R TC ompounds such as drugs, agrochemicals and plastics are prepared from simple chemical precursors through multistep synthetic routes. Accordingly, strategies that permit straightforward conversion of simple starting materials into the desired molecular structures, avoiding the additional steps and fancy tricks often needed for chemical transformations, are urgently needed. On page 489, Wang et al. 1 report a remarkable advance that addresses this issue using a strategy known as non-directed C-H functionalization.The basic components of all organic molecules are carbon and hydrogen atoms. The strong C-H bonds that form between these atoms account for the stability of organic molecules, but they also make it difficult to modify such molecules by selectively replacing hydrogen atoms with other chemical groups. Moreover, replacing a single hydrogen can be difficult without destroying the whole molecular system, because of the 'harsh' reaction conditions that are generally required. Solving these problems has been a real challenge for organic chemists, and has led to the establishment of a field known as C-H bond functionalization 2,3 . The most extensively explored solution involves using transition metals -particularly the noble metals, which under certain conditions are sufficiently active to cleave C-H bonds.Another fundamental issue is how to target one hydrogen selectively in the presence of many others that have very similar chemical because it deliberately positions itself as an exploratory data analysis across different environments and sample types. This produces certain constraints on the inferences that can be made, because environmental data collected for the samples were not always measured in the same way in different environments.The debate about the relative merits of datadriven and hypothesis-driven experimental approaches is not new, and there are examples of each of these approaches providing scientific insights. This study is an excellent example of the former, even if concessions had to be made regarding the selection of variables that could be used for analyses across all the environments.Thompson and colleagues made several findings. For example, they investigated whether existing theories about the relationship between species richness (as monitored by the diversity of 16S rRNA sequences) and temperature and pH across environments were consistent with their data. For example, there is a model that proposes a steady logarithmic rise of microbial richness with increasing temperature 7,8 . Surprisingly, in contrast to this theory, the authors found that microbial biodiversity peaks at a relatively narrow pH and temperature range and then drops again.The authors also observed an unexpectedly high amount of '...