Peasants Against MNCs and the State: The Role of the Bergama Struggle in the Institutional Construction of the Gold-Mining Field in Turkey

Abstract

In this article, we argue that the emergent literature that integrates the neo-institutional and social movement theories for a better understanding of institutional change offers a partial picture concerning the roles of the state and society in institutional wars due to its preoccupation with the liberal polities prevalent in the Anglo-Saxon countries. We suggest that the macro-institutional perspective that recognizes the influences of varied polities should be introduced to this emergent literature, if it is to provide a full picture. Incorporating the macro-institutional insights into the integrative approach, we examine a struggle between a group of protesters, a multinational gold-mining company and governmental actors regarding an environmental issue in Bergama, Turkey, where a statist polity mediates worldwide currents towards the neo-liberal order. The findings indicate that the Turkish state repressed the mobilizations against the neo-liberal construction of the mining field and reinforced the existing neo-liberal logic in the mining field through introducing a new regulatory framework. On the basis of the findings, we suggest that both the trajectory and consequences of institutional wars are influenced by the kind of polity in which they take place.

Interpreting Industry's Impacts: Micropolitical Ecologies of Divergent Community Responses

“…Therefore, they may place their power at the service of corporations, even foreign ones, protecting them by repressing — sometimes violently — any opposition to their activities and thus providing companies with ‘a powerful political and economic insurance policy’ (Leith, 2003: 3). Neoliberalism, encouraged in part by institutions such as the IMF, results in states’ readiness ‘to realize radical economic and political reforms by repressing, or at least disregarding, the demands of social groups hurt by the reforms’ (Özen and Özen, 2009: 563). Industries’ economic power over nations can also operate in more subtle ways.…”

Antecedents of firm performance in emerging economies: Business groups, strategy, industry structure, and state support

“…The present study acknowledges the role of state support for firm performance (Boratav, 1981;Bugra 2008, Hoskisson, Wright, Filatotchev andPeng, 2012;Malik and Kotabe, 2009;Özen and Akkemik, 2012;Özen and Özen, 2009), although the indirect effects of state interventionism, for example on industry structure, cannot be measured. The study proposes the following hypothesis.…”

A Corporate Social Responsibility Framework for Mining Sector Using Analytic Network Process

“…In addition, the criticisms are not limited with companies" home countries. With the developments in global economy and the effects of globalization, multinational companies that want to benefit from resources in different countries have extended their borders towards those countries; and so, their social and environmental impacts (Ozen & Ozen, 2009). As an example of that process, mining companies have started benefiting from the liberalizing tendencies in the global economy by shifting their operations from developed countries, where resources are getting scarce, to developing countries (Kapelus, 2002).…”

“…However, especially in developing countries, state"s priority is generally promoting the industrial development process in order to attract investments that create employment and revenue (Hamann, 2003). As a result, in many countries, there are neoliberal rhetoric that emphasizes the importance of mining activities and foreign investment for state economy and there are more flexible and less environmentally sensitive regulations, as in the case of Turkey (Ozen & Ozen, 2009).…”

“…In parallel with changing regulations in legislative framework and increasing number of foreign companies, several social movements and protests against mining activities became a hot topic in Turkey (e.g. Coban, 2004;Ozen, 2009aOzen, , 2009bOzen & Ozen, 2009. These social movements that appeared in areas such as Bergama, Izmir; Esme, Usak; Efemcukuru, Izmir; Balikesir; and Canakkale (Ozen & Ozen, 2010).…”