“…As indicated initially, I see hope for physical education in, for example, activist, appreciative, paradoxical and participatory approaches (Enright, Hill, Sandford, & Gard, 2014;Enright & O'Sullivan, 2010;Larsson et al, 2014;Luguetti et al, 2017;Oliver & Hamzeh, 2010;Oliver & Kirk, 2016). Other apt examples are the work on meaningful physical education (Fletcher, Ní Chróinín, Price, & Francis, 2018;Ní Chróinín, Fletcher, & O'Sullivan, 2018), social justice (Azzarito, Macdonald, Dagkas, & Fisette, 2017), or pedagogical cases such as those introduced by Armour (2014). But also at a policy level in Australia and Scotland, new curricula show promise (Carse, Jess, & Keay, 2018;Jess, Atencio, & Thorburn, 2011;Macdonald, 2013;McCuaig, Quennerstedt, & Macdonald, 2013;Thorburn, 2017;Thorburn & Horrell, 2014).…”