Chest pain in children and adolescents is a common reason for emergency department visits and referrals to pediatric cardiologists, often driven by parental concern about potential cardiac causes. However, the vast majority of pediatric chest pain cases are benign and non-cardiac in origin. This narrative review examines the etiology, evaluation, and management of pediatric chest pain, emphasizing the importance of a thorough clinical history and physical examination in distinguishing between benign and serious conditions. This review also explores the role of diagnostic tests such as electrocardiograms, chest radiography, and echocardiography, highlighting the need to balance the avoidance of unnecessary tests with the imperative to rule out life-threatening cardiac conditions. Despite the low prevalence of cardiac causes, the variability in diagnostic approaches underscores the need for standardized evaluation algorithms. These could streamline care, reduce unnecessary resource utilization, and minimize anxiety for both patients and their families. Future studies should focus on assessing the effectiveness of such algorithms in improving clinical outcomes and resource management. The findings underscore the importance of a careful, evidence-based approach to the management of pediatric chest pain.