Peer Review #1 of "Resolution-agnostic tissue segmentation in whole-slide histopathology images with convolutional neural networks (v0.1)"

Abstract

Modern pathology diagnostics is being driven towards large scale digitization of microscopic tissue sections. A prerequisite for its safe implementation is the guarantee that all tissue present on a glass slide can also be found back in the digital image. Whole-slide scanners perform a tissue segmentation in a low resolution overview image to prevent inefficient high-resolution scanning of empty background areas. However, currently applied algorithms can fail in detecting all tissue regions. In this study, we developed convolutional neural networks to distinguish tissue from background. We collected 100 whole-slide images of 10 tissue samples-staining categories from 5 medical centers for development and testing. Additionally, 8 more images of 8 unfamiliar categories were collected for testing only. We compared our fully-convolutional neural networks to 3 traditional methods on a range of resolution levels using Dice score and sensitivity. We also tested whether a single neural network can perform equivalently to multiple networks, each specialized in a single resolution. Overall, our solutions outperformed the traditional methods on all the tested resolutions. The resolution-agnostic network achieved average Dice scores between 0.97 and 0.98 across the tested resolution levels, only 0.0069 less than the resolution-specific networks. Finally, its excellent generalization performance was demonstrated by achieving averages of 0.98 Dice score and 0.97 sensitivity on the 8 unfamiliar images. A future study should test this network prospectively.