The management of thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura (TTP) presents a unique challenge in individuals who are unable to accept plasma due to religious beliefs, given that therapeutic plasma exchange (TPE) is the standard of care. A 61-year-old Jehovah’s Witness woman presented to our hospital with neurological symptoms and laboratory findings suggestive of TTP. On admission, she refused transfusion of blood products, specifically red blood cells, platelets, and plasma but accepted albumin and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG); fractions of plasma. She was started on steroids, IVIG, and TPE with albumin as replacement therapy with minimal improvement. After a detailed discussion with the patient and family, they agreed to accept cryosupernatant. The patient started TPE with cryosupernatant for replacement therapy, which resulted in clinical improvement. This case highlights the importance of an individualized approach with joint decision-making given the significant heterogeneity that exists in Jehovah’s Witnesses’ attitude toward the receipt of blood products.