Amyloid fibrils represent the structural endpoint on the energetic (mis)folding landscape of very many proteins. Physiologically, amyloid fibrils are observed as a characteristic hallmark in misfolding diseases often associated with degenerative and neurodegenerative disorders. In the beginning of the scientific discussion, the focus is laid on the fibrillar state, but over the time it becomes increasingly clear that low molecular weight and transient aggregates are of crucial importance for pathological mechanisms. Structural studies find different intra‐ and intermolecular contacts for the most well‐studied peptide amyloid β (Aβ) depending on the stage of fibrillation. In particular, the contact between residues phenylalanine 19 (F19) and leucine 34 (L34) seems to be highly conserved, suggesting that it must be of particular significance for Aβ misfolding and possibly the pathological properties of the peptide. This review aims to highlight the rational and the usefulness of point mutations in Aβ peptides and their impact on the critical interstrand contact F19−L34 depending on the stage of fibrillation. While the amyloid structure of Aβ is very robust against quite a few modifications, the toxicity of mutated Aβ molecules highly depends on the F19−L34 contact.