Perceived effectiveness of learning methods among preclinical medical students - role of personality and changes over time

Abstract

Background and Objectives: Active learning methods are vital in inculcating skills of critical thinking, lifelong learning and effective communication. Personality may influence learning method preferences and academic performance. The aim of this cross sectional study was to examine the relationship between students’ personality and their predilection for learning methods and academic performance.
 Methods: Perceived effectiveness of learning methods was assessed over time. Second- and third-year medical students (n=112) completed a questionnaire consisting of Big Five Inventory to measure the personality dimensions, and evaluated lecture, problem-based learning (PBL) and team-based learning (TBL) for their helpfulness in learning. Grade point average (GPA), PBL and TBL grades were obtained. Correlation coefficients were calculated between personality traits and learning method effectiveness scores, and grades. Learning methods effectiveness was compared between second- and third-year students.
 Results: Positive correlations were identified between conscientiousness and lecture (r = 0.30), agreeableness and lecture (r = 0.20), and agreeableness and TBL (r = 0.23). Likewise, positive correlations were seen between extraversion and PBL grade (r=0.20), and conscientiousness and GPA (r = 0.23). In third year, significant decline in perceived effectiveness of lecture was seen (81% vs 57%; p = 0.006), while increased perceived effectiveness for PBL (38% vs. 50%) was not statistically significant (p = 0.22).
 Conclusions: The findings provide an evidence for modest correlations between personality and perceived effectiveness of learning methods. Remarkably, perceived effectiveness decreased for the lecture and increased for the PBL over time. The findings may help educators in better implementing active learning modalities. Besides, an earlier introduction may help students becoming acquainted with and getting the most out of PBL.
 doi: https://doi.org/10.12669/pjms.37.7.4355
 How to cite this:Arain SA, Alhadid DA, Rasheed S, Alrefaai MM, Alsibai TMA, Meo SA. Perceived effectiveness of learning methods among preclinical medical students - role of personality and changes over time. Pak J Med Sci. 2021;37(7):---------. doi: https://doi.org/10.12669/pjms.37.7.4355
 This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Starting early: Case study of mentoring for undergraduate training through the Veterans Health Administration and implications for promoting equity.

“…In this case study, utilizing the preceptor model coupled with extensive didactic training and an applied research project appeared to aid in the completion of undergraduate collegiate degrees and pursual of further graduate education among students from both private and public institutions. The value of the preceptor and didactic model was consistent with the broader literature (Arain et al, 2021; Kantar, 2021), yet trainees’ feedback about VA-CERP suggests that additional unique elements of this program aided in their professional development including didactic training on the value of mental health research, clinical practice, public policy, and veteran care. Findings from this case study are consistent with extant literature highlighting the benefits of undergraduate mentorship and extracurricular research training and extending them to VHA where research on undergraduate programs has been limited.…”

“…The goal of the VA Center of Excellence Research Program (VA-CERP) is to provide motivated undergraduates striving to become future health care providers with quality mental health research experience and professional development. VA-CERP includes empirically supported components that promote undergraduate success and the transition to graduate school, including tiered mentorship (Burgess et al, 2018;Zaniewski & Reinholz, 2016), a didactic-preceptor model (Arain et al, 2021;Kantar, 2021), handson experience (Seymour et al, 2004;Stohr-Hunt, 1996), and participation on interdisciplinary teams (Aldriwesh et al, 2022;Spaulding et al, 2021), strongly aligning with several proposed solutions identified by the CCTC (2021). The tiered mentorship model embedded in our program affords our undergraduate students several sources of mentorship, ranging from midcareer doctoral level mentors, advanced postdoctoral fellows, and bachelor's and master's level preceptors, guiding students in developing their graduate school applications, composing personal statements, and interviewing for positions.…”

Medical students' perception and academic performance after team-based and seminar-based learning in human anatomy

“…The results showed that some students who are sensitive and tend to avoid conflict and confrontation preferred nearly equally both traditional lectures and TBL. 41 In the current study, it was surprising to find that approximately twice as many students preferred TBL over seminars, although their achievements in seminars were acceptable. Seminars are subject-centered or leader-centered, rather than participant-centered.…”