Perceived tax audit aggressiveness, tax control frameworks and tax planning: an empirical analysis

Abstract

This paper examines whether a perceived increase in tax audit aggressiveness is associated with lower tax planning effort and a higher quality of internal tax control frameworks. Using survey data on corporate tax functions from approximately 200 firms from different countries, contrary to expectations, we find that neither internal nor external resources devoted to tax planning are lower for firms that perceive an increase in tax audit aggressiveness. Nevertheless, for these firms, we find a positive association with the quality of their tax control framework and their investments in the reputation management and communication skills of their tax department staff. In line with this, we find that an increase in perceived audit aggressiveness is directly (indirectly) associated with an increase in resources allocated to the tax function “controversy and audit defense” (“risk management and governance”). In addition, our results show a positive relationship between the quality of the tax control framework and the need for comprehensive improvements in human capital and internal processes, suggesting that the tax control framework affects the firms' perceptions of their tax capabilities and drives organizational changes. Overall, these findings are in line with the rationale that an increase in audit aggressiveness changes the costs of compliance errors such that firms improve the quality of their tax control framework to reduce future errors. In contrast, it remains unclear whether tax audit aggressiveness actually changes tax planning behavior, as we find no negative association with the firms' investment in tax planning.

Tax control as a tool to curb the shadow economy

“…Несмотря на то, что при ВНП осуществляется проверка одной организации, иные участники схемы могут также стать кандидатами для проведения ВНП. [7]. Подводя итог, авторы выдвинули гипотезу о том, что повышение воспринимаемой агрессивности аудита связано с повышением качества отчетности организаций (налогоплательщиков).…”

Luxury tax perspectives: The evidence of the Republic of Belarus

“…The breadth and depth of the tax evasion and corporate tax avoidance matters by modern research are ranged from the morality of tax avoidance and inequality (Lokanan, 2023;Di Gioacchino, Fichera, 2020;Argentiero et al, 2021) to modeling of tax avoidance and implication of business digitalization and technologies on tax evasion (Gomes et al, 2023;Alm, 2021;Amzuică, Mititelu, & Nișulescu, 2023). Tax planning as a crucial part of ensuring a sound financial future and an important strategy that helps individuals and businesses to reduce their tax liability also has attracted increasing attention from researchers (Tartono, Hidayat, Haryono, 2021;Cheng et al, 2021;Zelmenis, 2022;Blaufus, Reineke, Trenn, 2023).…”

Exploring the involvement of tax audit experts in the early stages of tax audits

“…The existing literature emphasizes the importance of involving experts but often lacks a rigorous examination of the methodologies employed and the measurable outcomes (Kırmızı & Kocaoglu, (2022). By conducting empirical research and analyzing the effectiveness of involving tax legal audit experts in the early stages of tax audits, this study can fill these gaps ultimately providing practical recommendations to enhance compliance and improve tax audit outcomes, thus contributing significantly to the field (Blaufus et al, (2023). Therefore, this study will provide valuable insights into the potential benefits of involving tax legal audit experts during the early stages of tax audits.…”