Perception of medical students and residents about virtual interviews for residency applications in the United States

Abstract

Introduction Residency applications via virtual-interview could potentially mitigate the extensive cost and time required for customary in-person interviews. We outline the perception of medical students and residents on the use of virtual-interview for residency applications in lieu of in-person interviews. Methods We obtained 1824 responses from medical students and residents through an online questionnaire between March2019-Feb2020 in Texas-United States. The survey had 11 statements (five in favor of in-person interviews and 6 in favor of virtual interviews) that respondents could rank on a 5-point Likert scale. All statements' scores were summed based on the response given by each participant to create a total score between 11 and 55. The perception of the two groups was analyzed using an independent sample T-test and ANOVA. Results We received a total of 1711 responses from medical students and 113 from medical residents. Respondents were more female (82.2% of medical students and 47.8% of residents), with a mean age of 22.87±3.42 years old for medical students and 28.72±4.35 years old for residents. Both groups preferred in-person interviews; however, the residents were significantly more in favor (P = 0.03). Both groups agree that virtual-interviews should be as an option, though this was considerably higher in the medical students (P = 0.001). In the multivariate analysis, "travel distance" and "type of medical school" had a significant impact on choosing the virtual-interviews in both groups (p<0.01). Conclusions In-person interviews are favored by both medical students and residents compared to virtual-interview services in normal circumstances. However, both groups agree that programs should offer the option of having virtual-interviews as an available choice. Distance to an

Improving the online presence of residency programs to ameliorate COVID-19’s impact on residency applications

“…5,6 The necessary reliance on virtual interviews in the present cycle may also increase the utilization of alternative interview formats, such as the Multiple Mini Interview (MMI). [7][8][9] While some studies have determined that novel models like the MMI are reliable in evaluating candidates, other assessments have raised concerns, such as a decreased capacity for applicants to learn about programs. [8][9][10][11] These changes will similarly pose challenges to residency programs.…”

“…[7][8][9] While some studies have determined that novel models like the MMI are reliable in evaluating candidates, other assessments have raised concerns, such as a decreased capacity for applicants to learn about programs. [8][9][10][11] These changes will similarly pose challenges to residency programs. Away rotations and in-person interviews have been posited to facilitate a mutual fit between a program and its applicants by allowing students to gauge factors like an institution's culture, teaching style, and case mix.…”

The COVID‐19 pandemic as a catalyst for medical education innovation: A learner’s perspective

“…My cost of applying for fellowship was limited to my application fees alone, and I did not need to budget extra days away from residency training for travel. The virtual interview process appreciably lowered the cost for medical school applicants, too, and likely made the process more equitable for candidates of limited financial means 21 . The biggest disadvantage cited by many applicants this year was that it is hard to imagine life in a new city or the culture at a prospective training institution without visiting in‐person.…”

Virtual residency/fellowship interviews: The good, the bad, and the future

“…As applicants and programs adjust to the realities of virtual interviewing, this is likely an unfamiliar experience for all. While the benefits and shortcomings must be considered together, I, along with many of my peers, 2 continue to prefer traditional in-person interviews. As the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic makes inperson interviews difficult, applicants and programs must embrace the experience…”