Perceptions of Barriers to Patient Participation: Are They Due to Language, Culture, or Discrimination?

Abstract

Previous research has shown that ethnic minority patients participate less during medical encounters than patients from majority populations. Given the positive outcomes of active patient participation, such as higher understanding of information and better treatment adherence, interventions are required to enhance ethnic minority patients' participation levels. However, little is known about what patients perceive as barriers hindering their participation. This study therefore aimed to explore differences in perceptions of barriers to patient participation among ethnic minority and ethnic majority patients in general practice. Eight focus-groups with Turkish-Dutch and indigenous Dutch participants were performed. A semi-structured topic-list concerning patients' enabling and predisposing factors to participate, and physicians' responses guided the interviews. Interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim, and transcripts were analyzed using the constant comparison method described in Grounded Theory. Regarding Turkish-Dutch patients' enabling factors to participate, two perceptions of barriers were identified: (i) low Dutch language proficiency; (ii) a preference for an indirect communication style. Three perceptions of barriers to Turkish-Dutch patients' predisposition to participate were identified: (i) collectivistic values; (ii) power distance; (iii) uncertainty avoidance. Regarding doctors' responses, discrimination was identified among Turkish-Dutch patients as a perception of barrier to their patients' participation. None of these perceptions of barriers emerged among indigenous Dutch patients. This study contributes to our understanding of which perceptions of barriers might impede ethnic minority patients' level of patient participation. To enhance their participation, a combined intervention is needed, tackling the language barrier, raising awareness about cultural differences in values, and increasing doctors' cultural competencies to communicate adequately with ethnic minority patients.

Barriers to access to mental health services among Colombia outpatients

“…The stigma-discrimination complex related to mental disorders configures a sociocultural barrier to access to physical and mental health given that they limit the possibilities of comprehensive care (Asis & de Jesus, 2012; Campo-Arias et al, 2014; Jorm & Wright, 2008 ; Schinkel et al, 2019). The stigma-discrimination related to mental disorders appears in the negligence of the actors, of the executive and legislative branches of the state, which omit mental health in most health programmes, plans and systems, not only in developing countries like Colombia but also in developed countries (Burns, 2009; Campo-Arias et al, 2014).…”

Nephrologists’ experiences with patient participation when long-term dialysis is required

“…It thus has potential to mitigate the patient-professional tensions occurring from divergent priorities, as experienced by nephrologists in the current study. However, patients entering the ESRD trajectory may not be aware of their legal right to participate [ 32 , 40 ]. Nephrologists should therefore emphasise and encourage patient participation from their very first pre-dialytic patient meetings, as expressed by some of our study participants.…”

Culture, Self, and Medical Decision Making in Australia and China: A Structural Model Analysis

“…18,53,56,57 The imbalance of power within the doctor–patient dyad is often more weighted toward doctors because doctors are perceived by patients as someone who has the professional expertise to cure the disease whereas they cannot do it themselves. 29,53,54,58 This caused us to question the power dynamics within the doctor–patient relationship in Chinese culture.…”