Perceptions of negative health-care experiences and self-reported health behavior change in three racial and ethnic groups

Abstract

Objectives Our two study objectives were: (1) to understand the relationship between the perception of a previous negative health care experience and race/ethnicity, and how socio-demographic, access-to-health-care, and self-reported health variables modified this relationship and (2) to assess how many behaviors participants reported changing as a result of experiencing a perceived negative health care experience, which behaviors they changed, and if there were differences in patterns of change across racial/ethnic groups. Design We conducted a cross-sectional survey of a convenience sample of 600 African American, Mexican-Hispanic, and white adults in socioeconomically diverse neighborhoods in Chicago, IL. We used multivariable logistic regression to analyze the relationship between a perceived negative health care experience in the last 5 years and race/ethnicity. We summed and then calculated the percentage of people who changed each of the 10 behaviors and evaluated whether or not there were differences in behavior change across racial/ethnic groups. Principal Findings More than 32% of participants reported a perceived negative health care experience in the past 5 years. Participants who had a bachelor’s degree or above (OR; 2.95,95%CI:1.01–8.63), avoided needed care due to cost (OR:1.84,95%CI:1.11–3.06), or who reported fair/poor health (OR:3.58,95%CI:1.66–7.80) had significantly increased odds of reporting a negative health care experience. Of these people, 88% reported “sometimes/always” changing at least one health seeking behavior. There were no racial/ethnic differences in reporting negative experiences or in patterns of behavior change. Conclusions Race/ethnicity was not related to reporting a perceived negative health care experience or reported patterns of behavior change in response to that experience. However those who avoided care due to cost, were more highly educated, or who indicated poorer health status reported having a negative experience more often. Our findings suggest that the perception of a previous negative experience may influence subsequent health care seeking behaviors.

Perceived healthcare discrimination and well-being among older adults in the United States and Brazil

“…Discriminatory treatment in healthcare settings is a well-documented barrier to receiving medical care ( Schwei et al, 2017 ; Trivedi & Ayanian, 2006 ). Individuals who perceive discrimination in the healthcare setting are less likely to have primary care doctors ( Blanchard & Nicole Lurie, 2004 ), voluntarily receive treatment, and have good overall mental and physical health ( Burgess et al, 2007 ; Hausmann et al, 2008 ).…”

Perceptions of childhood asthma and its control among Malays in Malaysia: a qualitative study

“…This was similar to findings from another study and appeared to be a barrier in achieving good asthma control in children 45 . A previous study found the negative experience with healthcare provider influenced health-seeking behaviour 46 . Children should be reviewed for asthma even if the asthma is mild, as it could recur in adulthood, and childhood asthma is a risk factor for later developing pulmonary disease 47 .…”

Patient experiences in a public primary health care clinic: A South African case study

“…This could signal that one's expectations adjust after a previous negative consultation at the same provider. In addition, such negative encounters have been shown to affect patients' behaviour outside the clinical setting (Bayuo 2017;Schwei et al 2016). For example, patients in Ghana have reported opting-out of care in their nearby and designated facilities due to negative experiences (Bayuo 2017).…”