Perioperative and Postoperative Outcomes of Proximal Hip Fracture: A Comparison of Orthopedic and Geriatric Care Models

Abstract

IntroductionOrthogeriatric patients with femur fractures, despite their multiple comorbidities and associated healthcare costs, have a promising new approach. This approach suggests that most patients should be hospitalized in the geriatric department, with daily orthopedic follow-up. The potential for lower mortality rates through orthogeriatric co-management and dual care is a reason for hope in our field. MethodsThis study is retrospective and involved 285 patients with proximal hip fractures. Two treatment models were compared: hospitalization in orthopedic and geriatric departments with different treatment protocols. The study analyzed demographic data and postoperative outcomes. It also included an analysis of 26 patients who received conservative treatment. ResultsOur study revealed significant differences between patients hospitalized in the orthopedic and geriatric departments. Geriatric department patients, who were significantly older and had higher comorbidities, experienced extended hospitalization and higher mortality rates during hospitalization, at 30 days, and at one-year follow-up (p<0.05). Notably, a significantly higher proportion of geriatric patients were discharged to home rehabilitation at the end of hospitalization compared to orthopedic patients (17.5% vs. 7.4%; p<0.01). Among non-operated patients, the mortality rate was 57.7% compared to 16.5% in patients who underwent surgery during the one-year follow-up. DiscussionOur study suggests that elderly patients with hip fractures may benefit from management in the geriatric department. Despite experiencing significantly longer hospital stays, these patients have a higher likelihood of being discharged home compared to those managed in the orthopedic department. These findings have important implications for the care of orthogeriatric patients and may help guide future treatment strategies.