The partial synchronized spawning strategy adopted by some marine invertebrate broadcast-spawners can lead to the production of many distinct pools of larvae within a single reproductive cycle. Following the fate of these larval groups from birth to settlement with molecular markers might shed light on mechanisms regulating their population recruitment. Larvae and recruits of Mya arenaria, a partially spawning marine bivalve, were monitored and collected over 13 consecutive weeks during an entire reproductive cycle. Each sampled individual (n = 218) was sorted according to size (early veligers, late veligers, post-larval recruits) and genotyped at seven microsatellite loci for comparisons among samples and with adult reference samples (n = 270). While traditional differentiation statistics (e.g., pairwise Δ(ST), allelic richness) suggested the absence of sweepstakes reproductive success, the level of relatedness found within and among larvae and recruit samples suggested otherwise. Four samples out of ten were observed to have higher within-sample relatedness values than randomly expected, including the very first group of early veligers produced in the season (E1) and the last group of post-larvae who survived recruitment (P10). E1 individuals were also found to be more related than randomly expected to individuals of more than 80% of all other samples including the last surviving recruits (P8 and P10). These results suggest that the first larvae produced in the season were the most successful to survive recruitment. Results also show direct evidence for larval retention and demonstrate for the first time larval and post-larval kin aggregation in a marine bivalve.