Personal Finance Decisions with Untruthful Advisors: An Agent-Based Model

Abstract

Investors usually resort to financial advisors to improve their investment process until the point of complete delegation on investment decisions. Surely, financial advice is potentially a correcting factor in investment decisions but, in the past, the media and regulators blamed biased advisors for manipulating the expectations of naive investors. In order to give an analytic formulation of the problem, we present an Agent-Based Model formed by individual investors and a financial advisor. We parametrize the games by considering a compromise for the financial advisor (between a sufficient reward by bank and to keep her reputation), and a compromise for the customers (between the desired return and the proposed return by advisor), and incorporating the social psychological concepts of truthfulness and cognitive dissonance. Then we obtain the Nash equilibria and the best response functions of the resulting game. We also describe the parameter regions in which these points result acceptable equilibria. In this way, the greediness/naivety of the customers emerge naturally from the model. Finally, we focus on the efficiency of the best Nash equilibrium.

Multiagent Diffusion and Opinion Dynamics Model Interaction Effects on Controversial Products

“…Social psychologists study the behavioral adjustments of individuals in situational contexts [41,42]. When analyzing the impacts of group processes on individual decisions, their observations and research methods focus on social perceptions (personal attributes, attitudes, and changes in attitudes) and social influences (including the ideas of conformity and compliance, among others) .…”

Emergent task allocation and incentives: an agent-based model

“…The model simulates how tasks are assigned within an organization, incorporating different incentive systems to shape agent behavior. Agent-based modeling and simulation have been effective for examining organizational dynamics, especially in areas like organizational design (Blanco-Fernández et al 2023a, b, 2024Leitner and Behrens 2015), consumer behavior (Sonderegger-Wakolbinger and Stummer 2015;Ghanem et al 2022), finance (Czupryna 2022;Mastroeni et al 2023), innovation management (Stummer and Kiesling 2021;Haurand and Stummer 2018), and procurement and supply chain management (Strmenik et al 2021;Colon et al 2021). This approach has gained attention for its ability to offer a controlled environment for experiments, enabling researchers to tweak parameters and decision making rules.…”