Personas for Better Targeted eHealth Technologies: User-Centered Design Approach

Abstract

Background The full potential of eHealth technologies to support self-management and disease management for patients with chronic diseases is not being reached. A possible explanation for these lacking results is that during the development process, insufficient attention is paid to the needs, wishes, and context of the prospective end users. To overcome such issues, the user-centered design practice of creating personas is widely accepted to ensure the fit between a technology and the target group or end users throughout all phases of development. Objective In this study, we integrate several approaches to persona development into the Persona Approach Twente to attain a more holistic and structured approach that aligns with the iterative process of eHealth development. Methods In 3 steps, a secondary analysis was carried out on different parts of the data set using the Partitioning Around Medoids clustering method. First, we used health-related electronic patient record data only. Second, we added person-related data that were gathered through interviews and questionnaires. Third, we added log data. Results In the first step, 2 clusters were found, with average silhouette widths of 0.12 and 0.27. In the second step, again 2 clusters were found, with average silhouette widths of 0.08 and 0.12. In the third step, 3 clusters were identified, with average silhouette widths of 0.09, 0.12, and 0.04. Conclusions The Persona Approach Twente is applicable for mixed types of data and allows alignment of this user-centered design method to the iterative approach of eHealth development. A variety of characteristics can be used that stretches beyond (standardized) medical and demographic measurements. Challenges lie in data quality and fitness for (quantitative) clustering.

Generating user-driven patient personas to support preventive health care activities of rural-living unattached patients

“…Our study builds on existing strategies while providing a vivid process description to inform future research. While other persona development strategies have combined both quantitative and qualitative elements [ 33 ], few quantitative personas have included targeted end users in the final step of enhancing user segments. This novel approach contributes greater insights into how potential end-users can best be engaged to optimize and enrich the quality and completeness of personas.…”

“Systems seem to get in the way”: a qualitative study exploring experiences of accessing and receiving support among informal caregivers of people living with chronic kidney disease

“…Consideration of culture is also one dimension of equity which, as discussed above, requires further consideration during intervention development for caregivers [ 63 , 64 , 68 , 69 ]. Use of public contribution, engagement of caregivers with different cultural backgrounds during intervention development, and user-centred design approaches (e.g., creating personas) could be strategies to enhance acceptability and build empathy into interventions for caregivers [ 85 – 87 ].…”

Preferences for coaching strategies in a personalized virtual coach for emotional eaters: an explorative study

“…In future studies it is recommended that personas differ less from each other in person-related data such as socioeconomic status and background, but making the personas more comparable might have impact on the heterogeneity. Systematic methods have since been developed that underpin this problem ( Holden et al, 2017 ; Klooster et al, 2022 ). By using the computational method silhouette clustering a better consistency of personas could be achieved.…”