Pest risk assessment of Amyelois transitella for the European Union

Abstract

Following a request from the European Commission, the EFSA Panel on Plant Health performed a pest risk assessment of Amyelois transitella (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), the navel orangeworm, for the EU. The quantitative assessment considered two scenarios: (i) current practices and (ii) a requirement for chilled transport. The assessment focused on pathways of introduction, climatic conditions and cultivation of hosts allowing establishment, spread and impact. A. transitella is a common pest of almonds, pistachios and walnuts in California, which is the main source for these nuts imported into the EU. Based on size of the trade and infestation at origin, importation of walnuts and almonds from the USA was identified as the most important pathways for entry of A. transitella. Using expert knowledge elicitation (EKE) and pathway modelling, a median estimate of 2,630 infested nuts is expected to enter the EU each year over the next 5 years (90% certainty range (CR) from 338 to 26,000 infested nuts per year). However, due to estimated small likelihoods of transfer to a host, mating upon transfer and survival of founder populations, the number of populations that establish was estimated to be 0.000698 year −1 (median, 90% CR: 0.0000126-0.0364 year −1 ). Accordingly, the expected period between founding events is 1,430 years (median, 90% CR: 27.5-79,400 year). The likelihood of entry resulting in establishment is therefore considered very small. However, this estimate has high uncertainty, mainly concerning the processes of transfer of the insect to hosts and the establishment of founder populations by those that successfully transfer. Climate matching and CLIMEX modelling indicate that conditions are most suitable for establishment in the southern EU, especially around the Mediterranean basin. The median rate of natural spread was estimated to be 5.6 km/year (median, 90% CR 0.8-19.3 km/year), after an initial lag period of 3.1 year (mean, 90% CR 1.7-6.2 year) following the establishment of a founder population. If A. transitella did establish, estimated median yield losses in nuts were estimated to be in the order of 1-2% depending on the nut species and production system. A scenario requiring imports of nuts to be transported under chilled conditions was shown to provide potential to further reduce the likelihood of entry.

Including climate change in pest risk assessment: Current practices and perspectives for future implementation

“…A second example is the EFSA quantitative pest risk assessment for Elasmopalpus lignosellus (lesser cornstalk borer) (EFSA PLH Panel, 2023c). The analysis was based on the output of four regional climate models under the representative emission scenario RCP8.5 (Kriticos et al., 2012).…”

Risk assessment of Xanthomonas citri pv. viticola for the EU

“…In this phase, defined as ‘lag period’, the spread is limited and not homogeneous (it can change in the different directions; EFSA PLH Panel, 2022 ). At the end of this phase, Xcv is expected to reach a level of adaptation to local conditions to allow it to survive, reproduce and infect enough plants to effectively spread between vineyards by natural means (e.g.…”

Climate change: A guide for pest risk assessors and decision makers

“…It is therefore noteworthy that recently, requests from European Commission (EC) plant health risk managers to the EFSA Panel on Plant Health, which provides advice to the EC in the form of scientific opinions, have asked for the effect of climate change to be taken into account when requesting pest risk assessments of Leucinodes orbonalis , L. pseudorbonalis and Xanthomonas citri pv. viticola , which are pests currently found in tropical and sub‐tropical regions (EFSA Panel on Plant Health, 2023).…”