“…There is an essential need for caution in using the MMEs as evidence for crustal-mantle interaction or mixing and/or mingling between crustal-derived felsic and mantle-derived mafic magmas during formation of granitic rocks, especially where no independent evidence is found for such a process. In some previously studied granitoid plutons with enclaves that are in the intermediate composition range and exhibit similar mineral assemblage and isotopic compositions (e.g., Holden et al, 1991;Barbarin and Didier, 1992;Sergi, 1997;Asrat et al, 2004;Barbarin, 2005;Kaygusuz and Aydınçakır, 2009;Turnbull et al, 2010;Wolska, 2012;Xiong et al, 2012), the role of MMEs in evaluating the mixing and/or mingling processes between crustal-derived felsic and mantle-derived mafic magmas may have been overestimated. Instead, the MMEs in this setting can provide valuable information on emplacement mechanisms and incremental growth of granitoid plutons in continental crust (e.g., Paterson et al, 2003Paterson et al, , 2004Donaire et al, 2005;Paterson, 2005, 2010;, 2013Barbey et al, 2008;Economos et al, 2009;Caricchi et al, 2012;Zhang and Zhao, 2013).…”