“…We noted that stronger-binding organic ligands on Co(II) did not prevent Co metal formation under negative cathodic potentials in prior literature reports 42 ; however, in these prior studies, the electrolyte was acidic phosphate buffer (pH 2.2), and the cathodic reaction was hydrogen evolution, compared to the 1 M KHCO 3 solution (pH 8.9) studied in CO 2 reduction herein. The local pH is higher during electrochemical CO 2 reduction, particularly so at high current density (such as 225 mA cm −2 when we obtained the best CH 4 FE) 43 . The stability of Co δ+ based catalysts, including Co δ+ complexes 44 and ultra-small/thin cobalt oxides 45 , 46 , under negative potentials for electrocatalytic CO 2 reduction, has previously been reported.…”