Cavitary tuberculosis (TB) is difficult to cure and a site of relapse. Bedaquiline has been a wonder drug in the treatment of multidrug resistant TB, but emergence of resistance threatens its sustained success. To investigate the role of drug distribution in resistance development, we designed a novel laser-capture microdissection scheme to spatially resolve the penetration of bedaquiline in the necrotic center (caseum) of cavities, a recalcitrant site of disease. Working with preclinical models that form large necrotic lesions, we profiled bedaquiline and two next generation diarylquinolines TBAJ-587 and TBAJ-876. Drug concentrations were measured in laser-captured areas of cavity caseum as a function of time and distance from blood supply. To simulate drug coverage in patient cavities, the data were modeled, and drug penetration parameter estimates were linked to clinical plasma pharmacokinetics for bedaquiline and the new diarylquinolines. Pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic (PK-PD) simulations revealed that bedaquiline reaches efficacious concentrations in outer and deep caseum after several weeks to months and lingers at subtherapeutic concentrations up to 3 years after therapy ends. TBAJ-587 and TBAJ-876, currently in clinical development, achieve bactericidal concentrations in caseum more rapidly and shorten the window of suboptimal concentrations post treatment compared to bedaquiline. Simulations of clinically plausible dosing schemes were conducted to guide the design of clinical trials for cavitary TB and help mitigate resistance development. In summary, the slow kinetics of diffusion of bedaquiline into and out of cavity caseum creates spatio-temporal windows of subtherapeutic concentrations. Site-of-disease simulations of TBAJ-587 and TBAJ-876 predict reduced opportunities for resistance development.