Phenylboronic acids in crystal engineering: Utility of the energetically unfavorable syn,syn-conformation in co-crystal design

Abstract

Phenylboronic acids can exist, in principle, in three different conformers (syn,syn; syn,anti and anti,anti) with distinct energy profiles. In their native state, these compounds prefer the energetically favored syn,anti-conformation. In molecular complexes, however, the functionality exhibits conformational diversity. In this paper we report a series of co-crystals, with N-donor compounds, prepared by a design strategy involving the synthons based on the syn,syn-conformation of the boronic acid functionality. For this purpose, we employed compounds with the 1,2-diazo fragment (alprazolam, 1H-tetrazole, acetazolamide and benzotriazole), 1,10-phenanthroline and 2,2'-bipyridine for the co-crystallization experiments. However, our study shows that the mere presence of the 1,2-diazo fragment in the coformer does not guarantee the successful formation of co-crystals with a syn,syn-conformation of the boronic acid.Typical cyclic OH···N hydrogen bonds formed by boronic acids with alprazolam (a) and 1,10-phenanthroline (b).The -B(OH) 2 fragment makes unsymmetrical O-H···N heterosynthons with alprazolam (ALP) and 1,10-phenanthroline (PHEN). In the co-crystals of phenylboronic acids with 1H-tetrazole (TETR) and 2,2'-bipyridine (BPY), the symmetrical boronic acid dimer is the major synthon. In the BPY complex, boronic acid forms linear chains and the pyridine compound interacts with the lateral OH of boronic acid dimers that acts as a connector, thus forming a ladder structure. In the TETR complex, each heterocycle interacts with three boronic acids. While two boronic acids interact using the phenolic group, the third molecule generates O-H···N hydrogen bonds using the extra OH group, of -B(OH) 2 fragment, left after the dimer formation. Thus, although molecules were selected retrosynthetically with the 1,2-diazo fragment or with nearby hetero-atoms to induce co-crystal formation using the syn,syn-orientation of the -B(OH) 2 functionality, co-crystal formation is in fact selective and is probably driven by energy factors. Acetazolamide (ACET) contains self-complementary functional groups and hence creates stable homosynthons. Phenylboronic acids being weak competitors fail to perturb the homosynthons and hence the components crystallize separately. Therefore, besides the availability of possible hydrogen bond acceptors in the required position and orientation, the ability of the phenyl-boronic acid to perturb the existing interactions is also a prerequisite to form co-crystals. This is illustrated in the 1910 Varughese S, et al. Sci China Chem December (2011) Vol.54 No.12 table below. In the case of ALP, PHEN and BPY, the native structures are stabilized by weak interactions and may be influenced by the boronic acid fragment. Thus phenylboronic acids can attain co-crystals with those compounds, wherein the cyclic O-H···N hydrogen bonds are stronger than the individual homo-interactions. This can lower the lattice energy of the molecular complex as compared with the individual crystals.Heterosynthons formed by boronic a...

Equivalence of Ethylene and Azo-Bridges in the Modular Design of Molecular Complexes: Role of Weak Interactions

“…[19][20][21][22] Isoreticular synthesis 23,24 and secondary building unit 25-27 approaches in metal−organic frameworks, and isostructurality [28][29][30] and modularity [31][32][33][34] in organic assemblies are a few thriving strategies in crystal engineering.…”

Zwitterionic Systems Obtained by Condensation of Heteroaryl‐Boronic Acids and Rhodizonic Acid

“…[50][51][52] The outcome has been, admittedly, unexpected affording an entirely new class of adducts, which, for their zwitterionic nature may well prove useful in the construction of frameworks or supramolecular aggregates. From solution, slow cooling of the liquid leads predominantly to retrieve crystals of the "axle" compound while mechanochemical reaction between boronic acid and rhodizonic acid affords exclusively the tweezer-type compounds.…”

From China to the world: Science China Chemistry celebrates the International Year of Chemistry

“…Gautam R. Desiraju and coworkers showed a design strategy for the preparation of co-crystals containing compounds in energetically unfavorable conformations. They used compounds with the 1,2-diazo fragment (such as alprazolam, 1H-tetrazole, acetazolamide and benzotriazole), 1,10-phenanthroline, and 2,2'-bipyridine for the co-crystallization studies ( Figure 6) [21]. Their work "shows that the mere presence of the 1,2-diazo fragment in the coformer does not guarantee the successful formation of co-crystals with a syn,syn-conformation of the boronic acid" [21].…”

“…Jianhua Cheng and Zhaomin Hou gave a short comment on rare-earth dialkyl and dihydride Figure 6 Graphic abstract of the paper by Desiraju et al [21].…”