Phonatory Dysfunction as a Preclinical Symptom of Huntington Disease

Abstract

PurposeAlthough dysphonia has been shown to be a common sign of Huntington disease (HD), the extent of phonatory dysfunction in gene positive premanifest HD individuals remains unknown. The aim of the current study was to explore the possible occurrence of phonatory abnormalities in prodromal HD.MethodSustained vowel phonations were acquired from 28 premanifest HD individuals and 28 healthy controls of comparable age. Data were analysed acoustically for measures of several phonatory dimensions including airflow insufficiency, aperiodicity, irregular vibration of vocal folds, signal perturbations, increased noise, vocal tremor and articulation deficiency. A predictive model was built to find the best combination of acoustic features and estimate sensitivity/specificity for differentiation between premanifest HD subjects and controls. The extent of voice deficits according to a specific phonatory dimension was determined using statistical decision making theory. The results were correlated to global motor function, cognitive score, disease burden score and estimated years to disease onset.ResultsMeasures of aperiodicity and increased noise were able to significantly differentiate between premanifest HD individuals and controls (p<0.01). The combination of these aspects of dysphonia led to a sensitivity of 91.5% and specificity of 79.2% to correctly distinguish speakers with premanifest HD from healthy individuals. Some form of disrupted phonatory function was revealed in 68% of our premanifest HD subjects, where 18% had one affected phonatory dimension and 50% showed impairment of two or more dimensions. A relationship between pitch control and cognitive score was also observed (r = −0.50, p = 0.007).ConclusionsPhonatory abnormalities are detectable even the in premotor stages of HD. Speech investigation may have the potential to provide functional biomarkers of HD and could be included in future clinical trials and therapeutic interventions.

The diagnostic utility of patient-report and speech-language pathologists’ ratings for detecting the early onset of bulbar symptoms due to ALS

“…Similar instrumentation-based measures have also been shown to be sensitive to subtle or pre-symptomatic speech changes associated with Parkinson’s disease (18,19) and Huntington’s disease (20, 21). Although these measures show promise for early detection, most instrumentation-based approaches are not currently well-suited for clinical evaluations, due to the cost of the equipment, and the time and expertise required for data collection, analysis, and interpretation.…”

Vocal Markers from Sustained Phonation in Huntington’s Disease

“…We rely on the fact that individuals with Huntington's Disease can exhibit different disorders during speech [4,5] and language production [6,7]. Motor speech disorders in Huntington's Disease are commonly referred to as hyperkinetic dysarthria [8]: variable rate, abnormal prosody, imprecise consonants and distorted vowels, phonation deviations, and sudden forced breath.…”

Porcine Model of Huntington's Disease

“…It is also known that large majority of HD patients, more than 90%, develop voice and speech dysfunction, abnormalities in speech timing, articulation deficits and irregular loudness [64]. Some of these symptoms start already before the onset of the disease [64][65][66][67][68]. Pigs have similar articular organs as humans, and thus, similar motor disturbances like rigidity, chorea and bradykinesia can be expected.…”