“…Regarding metal catalysts [e.g., Cu (Wei et al, 2016), Ir (Wang et al, 2007) and Sb (Kou et al, 2020)], Zhou et al (2020) used semi-embedded carbon felt with bismuth nanospheres, which had good catalytic activity and could effectively promote the redox reaction of the negative electrode. For metal oxides [e.g., Nd 2 O 3 (Fetyan et al, 2018), MnO 2 (Ma et al, 2018), and PbO 2 (Wu et al, 2014)], Bayeh et al (2020) (Etesami et al, 2018)], Park et al (2013) demonstrated that carbon nanofiber/nanotube composite catalysts had good electrocatalytic performance in VRFB. Compared with the untreated electrode, the discharge capacity of the modified electrode increased by 64% at 40 mA cm −2 .…”