Both photo-and biocatalysis are well-established and intensively studied. The combination of these two approaches is also an emerging research field, commonly referred to as semi-artificial photosynthesis. Semi-artificial photosynthesis aims at combining highly efficient synthetic light harvesters with the self-healing and potent catalytic properties of biocatalysis. In this study, a semi-artificial photocatalytic system featuring Escherichia coli bacteria, which heterologously express the [FeFe] hydrogenase enzyme HydA1 from green algae, is employed as a hydrogen gas production catalyst. To probe the influence of photochemistry on overall system performance, the E. coli whole-cell catalyst is combined with two different photosensitizers and redox mediators. The addition of a redox mediator greatly improves the rates and longevity of the photocatalytic system, as reflected in increases of both the turn-over number (0.777 vs 10.9 μmol H 2 mL −1 OD 600 −1) and the turn-over frequency (175 vs 334 μmol H 2 mL −1 h −1 OD 600 −1). The redox mediator is found to both protect from photobleaching and enable electron transport to the hydrogenase from an extracellular photosensitizer. However, E. coli cells are strongly affected by the photocatalytic system, leading to a decrease in cell integrity and cell viability, possibly due to toxic decomposition products formed during the photocatalytic process. We furthermore employed steady-state and transient absorption spectroscopy to investigate solution potentials and the kinetics of electron transfer processes between the sacrificial electron donor, photosensitizer, redox mediator, and the [FeFe] hydrogenase as the final electron acceptor. These results allowed us to rationalize the different activities observed in photocatalytic assays and offer a better understanding of the factors that influence the photocatalytic performance of E. coli-based whole-cell systems.