The quantum efficiency of photosynthetic energy conversion was investigated in isolated spinach chloroplasts by measurements of the quantum requirements of ATP formation by cyclic and noncyclic photophosphorylation catalyzed by ferredoxin. ATP formation had a requirement of about 2 quanta per 1 ATP at 715 nm (corresponding to a requirement of 1 quantum per electron) and a requirement of 4 quanta per ATP (corresponding to a requirement of 2 quanta per electron) at 554 nm. When cyclic and noncyclic photophosphorylation were operating concurrently at 554 nm, a total of about 12 quanta was required to generate the two NADPH and three ATP needed for the assimilation of one CO2 to the level of glucose.Few areas of photosynthesis have received more intensive theoretical and experimental study and generated more controversy than the efficiency with. which photosynthetic cells convert the electromagnetic energy of light into chemical energy (for review, see refs. 1 and 2). Two different concepts, never reconciled during the lifetimes of their main protagonists, emerged from the many investigations. One concept, espoused by Warburg et al. (3), was that photosynthetic quantum conversion has an efficiency of about 90%-i.e., that energy equivalent to that of 3 einsteins of red quanta (42 kcal each) is sufficient to liberate 1 mol of 02 (corresponding to 1/6 mol of glucose, for which AGO' = 686/6 = 114 kcal). In contrast, Emerson (4) and his followers (5) concluded that photosynthetic efficiency was much lower, of the order of 8 to 12 quanta per 02, a range that is widely accepted today even though values less than 8 have, at times, been obtained by investigators (6, 7) who did not share Warburg's conclusions.Most studies of photosynthetic quantum efficiency were based on measurements of light-induced production of 02 (corrected for concurrent respiration) during complete photosynthesis by whole cells, usually unicellular algae of the Chlorella type. Discordant results were attributed to experimental variables such as errors in methods (usually manometric) of 02 measurement, variations in the concurrent 02 consumption by respiration, participation of respiratory intermediates in photosynthesis, need for supplementary (catalytic) illumination, and nutritional history, age, and physiological status of the cells (1-5). Left unchallenged, however, was the main (and, to us, dubious) premise underlying these studies with whole cells-namely, that the photoproduction of 1 mol of 02 always corresponds to the assimilation of 1 mol of CO2 to the level of glucose and that, therefore, 02 evolution is a reliable measure of the total amount of chemical energy stored.A different perspective and experimental approach to the question of photosynthetic quantum efficiency emerged from studies of photosynthesis by isolated chloroplasts in which the process was physically separated into a light phase concerned with cyclic and noncyclic photophosphorylation and a "dark," enzymatic phase concerned with the assimilation of CO2 (8).Fractiona...