Physical activity, diet, and weight loss in patients recruited from primary care settings: An update on obesity management interventions

Abstract

Background: Obesity and related comorbidities are the most common chronic conditions in North America where behavior modification including the adoption of physical activity (PA) and a healthful diet are primary treatment strategies. Patients are more likely to engage in behavior modification if encouraged by their physician; however, behavioral counseling in primary care rarely occurs due to lack of training and resources. A more effective method may be to refer patients from clinical settings to other health professionals.Objective: This systematic review examines the effectiveness of behavior-based counseling for obesity management among participants referred from clinical settings. Methods: PubMed, CINAHL, and EMBASE were used to identify randomized clinical trials (2014-2020) for weight loss with the following inclusion criteria: trial duration ≥12 months, included a control or usual care group, recruited adults with overweight or obesity from primary care and/or treated in the primary care setting, and the intervention included counseling on PA and diet.Results: Seventeen studies, encompassing 21 different intervention groups with 6185 unique participants (56% female) met the inclusion criteria. All participants had overweight or obesity, with a body mass index between 28.2 and 41.0 kg/m 2 . In 11 (52%) of the intervention groups, significant weight loss in the intervention group was observed compared to usual care (mean weight loss: 4.9[2.1] kg vs. 1.0 [0.9] kg). In 13 out of 18 interventions (72%) reporting weight loss at two time points, weight regain was observed by 12 months. Statistically significant weight loss was observed in one intervention (of two total) that was longer than 12 months. Conclusions: Sustained weight loss regardless of the behavior-based, intervention strategy remains a challenge for most adults. Given the established benefits of routine PA and a healthful diet, prioritizing the adoption of healthy behaviors regardless of weight loss may be a more effective strategy for ensuring long-term health benefit.

Understanding the Perspectives of Latino Adults Who Smoke on Physical Activity: A Qualitative Study

“…Interventions to increase physical activity should limit their focus on weight management, as it can make individuals feel that physical activity is not improving their health if they are not losing weight [ 42 ]. Interventions should focus on the fact that independent of weight, physical activity is a good activity for everybody [ 43 , 44 ].…”

Game changers: do new medications make lifestyle‐based treatment of obesity obsolete?

“…This translational gap is unsurprising given a health care system whose payment models are misaligned for supporting lifestyle interventions, a medical workforce that lacks training on delivering lifestyle-based treatment, and weak public health infrastructure for community intervention delivery. Without major health system reform, as well as sustained investment to facilitate intervention delivery that approximates the fidelity seen in clinical trials, translating lifestyle interventions into real-world settings will continue to produce modest results [5,6].…”

Medical Weight Management: A Multidisciplinary Approach

“…Lifestyle modification programs can be implemented in many venues e.g., specialized obesity clinics, primary care, commercial, private dietetics practice or academic medical centers [13][14][15][16]. Typically, these programs induce modest WL that results in significant improvement in obesity-associated health conditions (sleep apnea, T2D, hypertension, hyperlipidemia) as well as positive psycho-social effects (mood, quality of life, body image) [17,18]. Several studies have demonstrated the efficacy of life style modification in promoting WL and improving obesity-associated comorbidities.…”