Physical Therapy Management of Nontraumatic Shoulder Problems Lacks High-Quality Clinical Practice Guidelines: A Systematic Review With Quality Assessment Using the AGREE II Checklist

Abstract

Objectives To appraise the quality of clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) for physical therapy management of nontraumatic shoulder pain disorders. Design Systematic review of CPGs. Literature Search Two reviewers independently conducted a search of 7 databases and 7 gray literature sources. Study Selection Criteria We included systematically developed CPGs for physical therapy management of nontraumatic musculoskeletal conditions of the shoulder in adults that were available in full text in the English language. We excluded CPGs for physical therapy management of surgically treated shoulder pain disorders. Data Synthesis Three reviewers independently rated the quality of included CPGs using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) instrument. Data were compiled into tables that displayed AGREE II domain scores for each CPG and mean item scores across the CPGs. Results We included 9 CPGs. Five CPGs focused on rotator cuff disorders, 2 focused on frozen shoulder, and 2 covered a range of soft tissue shoulder diagnoses. Three CPGs were judged as high quality (all were 5 or more years old) and 6 were judged as low quality. The quality domains in which CPGs were rated highest were “scope and purpose” (all CPGs scored greater than 50% and 4 scored greater than 80%) and “clarity of presentation” (all CPGs scored greater than 50% and 7 scored greater than 80%). The domains in which CPGs were rated most poorly were “applicability” (6 CPGs scored 40% or less) and “editorial independence” (4 CPGs scored less than 40%). Conclusion There were no high-quality, contemporary CPGs to guide physical therapy management of nontraumatic shoulder pain. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2021;51(2):63–71. Epub 25 Dec 2020. doi:10.2519/jospt.2021.9397

Managing shoulder pain: a meta-ethnography exploring healthcare providers’ experiences

“…This lack of consensus has been highlighted previously [4], with numerous studies highlighting the varied opinions and practices of HCPs in relation to the management of shoulder pain [12,19,[53][54][55]. The reasons for this variation is likely to be multifactorial, influenced by the impact of inconsistent research findings, a lack of high quality clinical practice guidelines [56], different guidelines and recommendations produced by and targeted to individual HCP discipline groups [3,9], and also the individual role and expertise of the HCP with different levels of training and emphases in professional education. It was highlighted in one recent survey that physiotherapists are more likely to prescribe physical therapy as the 1st line treatment for rotator cuff tears, and surgeons are more likely to recommend surgery [19].…”

Identifying Conservative Interventions for Individuals with Subacromial Pain Syndrome Prior to Undergoing a Subacromial Decompression: A Scoping Review

“…This makes determining exercise type, dose, duration, timing, and expected outcomes recommendations difficult. 13,89 CONCLUSION Conservative management for SAPS offers an equally advantageous outcome when compared to SAD. Many individuals continue to receive a SAD despite conservative care, bringing into question what is "adequate care" for individuals with shoulder pain.…”

Designing multimedia patient education materials for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis: a protocol for a feasibility randomized controlled trial of patient education videos

“…Patient education is a pillar of treatment that is recommended in many aspects of musculoskeletal (MSK) care, [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10] including adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS). [11,12] Multimedia education is one option for conveying some of the information that healthcare providers may wish to pass on to a patient.…”