Physician mothers’ experience of workplace discrimination: a qualitative analysis

Abstract

ObjectivesTo report woman physicians’ experiences, in their own words, of discrimination based on their role as a mother.DesignQualitative analysis of physician mothers’ free-text responses to the open question: “We want to hear your story and experience. Please share” included in questions about workplace discrimination. Three analysts iteratively formulated a structured codebook, then applied codes after inter-coder reliability scores indicated high concordance. The relationships among themes and sub-themes were organized into a conceptual model illustrated by exemplary quotes.ParticipantsRespondents to an anonymous, voluntary online survey about the health and wellbeing of physician mothers posted on a Facebook group, the Physician Moms Group, an online community of US physicians who identify as mothers.ResultsWe analyzed 947 free-text responses. Participants provide diverse and vivid descriptions of experiences of maternal discrimination. Gendered job expectations, financial inequalities (including lower pay than equally qualified colleagues and more unpaid work), limited opportunities for advancement, lack of support during the pregnancy and postpartum period, and challenging work-life balance are some of the key themes identified. In addition, participants’ quotes show several potential structural drivers of maternal discrimination and describe the downstream consequences of maternal discrimination on the physician herself, her career, family, and the healthcare system.ConclusionsThese findings provide a view of maternal discrimination directly from the perspective of those who experience it. Women physicians report a range of previously uncharacterized ways in which they experience maternal discrimination. While certain aspects of these experiences are consistent with those reported by women across other professions, there are unique aspects of medical training and the medical profession that perpetuate maternal discrimination.

Pregnancy and Maternity at Workplace, a Qualitative Study to Know the Employers’ Perspective

“…They not only expressed their agreements on working of women but also providing them with the environment conducive to their working while pregnant. When same thing was discussed with the executive managers who were responsible for implementation of policies formulated at higher levels, they showed some reservations [8] .…”

Gender equity in obstetrics and gynaecology – where are we heading?

“…9 Women obstetricians and gynaecologists in training and in practice face more significant challenges than their male counterparts if and when they have children, since a much greater physical and temporal burden falls upon them with pregnancy, childbirth and child-rearing even when partners are extremely accommodating and taking on a major part of the childcare responsibilities. [10][11][12][13][14] What is clear is that what happens over the next few years in terms of intake into the training programs will have enormous influence on the nature and composition of the obstetric and gynaecological workforce for many years to come, and therefore on the nature and composition of the working structure of the…”

TIME’S UP Healthcare: Can we put an end to gender inequality and harassment in medicine?

“…TIME’S UP Healthcare focuses not only on sexual harassment, but also on gender discrimination 67. Since unequal power dynamics are at the root of both harassment and discrimination, these problems are worse for women from ethnic minorities or for those belonging to other marginalised groups.…”