Physicians’ attitudes toward medical and ethical challenges for patients in the vegetative state: comparing Canadian and German perspectives in a vignette survey

Abstract

BackgroundPhysicians treating patients in the vegetative state (VS) must deal with uncertainty in diagnosis and prognosis, as well as ethical issues. We examined whether physicians’ attitudes toward medical and ethical challenges vary across two national medical practice settings.MethodsA comparative survey was conducted among German and Canadian specialty physicians, based on a case vignette about the VS. Similarities and differences of participants’ attitudes toward medical and ethical challenges between the two samples were analyzed with non-parametric tests (Mann-Whitney-U-Test).ResultsThe overall response rate was 13.4%. Eighty percent of all participants correctly applied the diagnostic category of VS with no significant differences between countries. Many of the participants who chose the correct diagnosis of VS attributed capabilities to the patient, particularly the ability to feel pain (70%), touch (51%) and to experience hunger and thirst (35%). A large majority of participants (94%) considered the limitation of life-sustaining treatment (LST) under certain circumstances, but more Canadian participants were in favor of always limiting LST (32% vs. 12%; Chi-square: p < 0.001). Finding long-term care placement was considered more challenging by Canadian participants whereas discontinuing LST was much more challenging for German participants.ConclusionsDifferences were found between two national medical practice settings with respect to physicians’ experiences and attitudes about treatment limitation about VS in spite of comparable diagnostic knowledge.

Persistent Vegetative State and Minimally Conscious State

“…Such measures do not bear an automatic legitimation; at every point along the patient's course, they should be provided if and only if they are ethically and legally justified. The readiness to treat patients with impaired consciousness with all necessary means of nursing and medical support now varies from one country to another (39).…”

The living dead? Perception of persons in the unresponsive wakefulness syndrome in Germany compared to the USA

“…Kuehlmeyer and colleagues investigated the same question in German and Canadian physicians and here as many as 70% ascribed the ability to feel pain to UWS patients. Another 51% believed that patients are able to feel touch and 21% of the physicians even were convinced that UWS patients can experience dreams [ 47 ].…”

Effects of percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy on survival of patients in a persistent vegetative state after stroke

“…PVS imposes a heavy burden on patient's families and the society at large, also raising many legal and ethical issues (Jennett , Kuehlmeyer et al . ).…”