We report a study of the role of material’s conductivity in determining the morphology of nanoparticles and nanostructures produced by ultrafast laser ablation of solids. Nanoparticles and textured surfaces formed by laser ablation display a wide variation in size and morphology depending on the material. In general, these qualities can be grouped as to material type, insulator, semiconductor, or metal; although each has many other different material properties that make it difficult to identify the critical material factor. In this report, we study these nanoparticle/ surface structural characteristics as a function of silicon (Si) resistivity, thus honing-in on this critical parameter and its effects. The results show variations in morphology, optical and non-linear properties of Si nanoparticles. The yield of colloidal Si nanoparticles increased with an increase in the conductivity of Si. Laser-induced periodic surface structures (LIPSS) formed on ablated substrates are also found to be sensitive to the initial conductivity of the material. Further, the laser ablation of Gamma-irradiated Si has been investigated to verify the influence of altered conductivity on the formation of Si nanoparticles. These observations are interpreted using the basic mechanisms of the laser ablation process in a liquid and its intricate relation with the initial density of states and thermal conductivities of the target material.