PIV-Measured Versus CFD-Predicted Flow Dynamics in Anatomically Realistic Cerebral Aneurysm Models

Abstract

Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modeling of nominally patient-specific cerebral aneurysms is increasingly being used as a research tool to further understand the development, prognosis, and treatment of brain aneurysms. We have previously developed virtual angiography to indirectly validate CFD-predicted gross flow dynamics against the routinely acquired digital subtraction angiograms. Toward a more direct validation, here we compare detailed, CFD-predicted velocity fields against those measured using particle imaging velocimetry (PIV). Two anatomically realistic flow-through phantoms, one a giant internal carotid artery (ICA) aneurysm and the other a basilar artery (BA) tip aneurysm, were constructed of a clear silicone elastomer. The phantoms were placed within a computer-controlled flow loop, programed with representative flow rate waveforms. PIV images were collected on several anterior-posterior (AP) and lateral (LAT) planes. CFD simulations were then carried out using a well-validated, in-house solver, based on micro-CT reconstructions of the geometries of the flow-through phantoms and inlet/outlet boundary conditions derived from flow rates measured during the PIV experiments. PIV and CFD results from the central AP plane of the ICA aneurysm showed a large stable vortex throughout the cardiac cycle. Complex vortex dynamics, captured by PIV and CFD, persisted throughout the cardiac cycle on the central LAT plane. Velocity vector fields showed good overall agreement. For the BA, aneurysm agreement was more compelling, with both PIV and CFD similarly resolving the dynamics of counter-rotating vortices on both AP and LAT planes. Despite the imposition of periodic flow boundary conditions for the CFD simulations, cycle-to-cycle fluctuations were evident in the BA aneurysm simulations, which agreed well, in terms of both amplitudes and spatial distributions, with cycle-to-cycle fluctuations measured by PIV in the same geometry. The overall good agreement between PIV and CFD suggests that CFD can reliably predict the details of the intra-aneurysmal flow dynamics observed in anatomically realistic in vitro models. Nevertheless, given the various modeling assumptions, this does not prove that they are mimicking the actual in vivo hemodynamics, and so validations against in vivo data are encouraged whenever possible.

Rest versus Exercise Hemodynamics for Middle Cerebral Artery Aneurysms: A Computational Study

“…While 3D PC-MRA correlates well with laser Doppler velocimetry in straight arteries, intra-aneurysmal flows are frequently slow and highly disturbed; in such regions, obtaining a high signal intensityto-noise ratio is difficult. 16 Ford et al 17 found that pulsatile intra-aneurysmal hemodynamics obtained from CFD captured the gross and finer flow details compared with particleimage velocimetry.…”

Hemodynamics of 8 Different Configurations of Stenting for Bifurcation Aneurysms

“…Although the main hemodynamic features are thought to be preserved, 32 these simplifications may cause differences between the results of CFD simulation and the in vivo state. Specifically, the present CFD study has the following limitations: First, single vascular geometry was examined.…”

Computational Hemodynamics in Cerebral Aneurysms: The Effects of Modeled Versus Measured Boundary Conditions

“…Waveforms are usually obtained from population-averaged measurements taken on healthy volunteers. 14,43 While the use of such waveforms remains the most popular method of BC application (17 out of 18 non-patient-specific BCs in our review), the method carries important limitations. First, as these measurements are taken in a healthy population, they may not be representative of patient waveforms.…”