Place attachment and challenges of historic cities

Garcia, Gabriela; Vandesande, Aziliz; Balen, Koen Van

doi:10.1108/jchmsd-08-2017-0054

Cited by 9 publications

(5 citation statements)

References 7 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Activity in historical places has significant component that affects individual attachment (Karsono et al, 2016;Garcia et al, 2018;Stylidis, 2017). Historical places provide a functional connection to a wide range of activities.…”

Section: Character Of Placementioning

confidence: 99%

“…Historical places provide a functional connection to a wide range of activities. The character of a place has defined by physical features such as architecture (Stylidis, 2017) and monuments (Garcia et al, 2018). Public places, scenery, and temperature are more variables that contribute to the character of the place (Ózkan & Yolmaz, 2019).…”

Section: Character Of Placementioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Place Attachment at the Ritual Bakar Tongkang for Heritage Tourism in Bagansiapiapi

Aldy,

Ginting,

Siagian

et al. 2024

E-BPJ

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

A concept of place attachment is required to understand the relationship between humans and the tourism environment. The concepts have been integrated into spatial studies with no universal agreement to explain the human-place bond. This systematic literature review focuses on the relationship between place attachment and heritage tourism using the PRISMA principles. This research proposes a conceptualization focus on the ritual approach as a human-place relationship. The place attachment conceptual framework has been influenced by multiple variables such as familiarity, length of engagement, emotional attachment, place character, and rituals. In contrast, heritage tourism's conceptual framework is influenced by curiosity and authenticity.

show abstract

Section: Character Of Placementioning

confidence: 99%

Section: Character Of Placementioning

confidence: 99%

Place Attachment at the Ritual Bakar Tongkang for Heritage Tourism in Bagansiapiapi

Aldy,

Ginting,

Siagian

et al. 2024

E-BPJ

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…A range of quantitative and qualitative methods and techniques-surveys and interviews, writing historical narratives, and mapping-have been used to collect perceptual data. Indeed, anthropological and ethnographic methodologies are of interest to heritage fields (Mason 2002, Garcia et al 2018). Surveys and interviews, which can either strategically focus on key stakeholders or, more broadly, target all the members of the whole community, are most commonly used.…”

Section: How To Capture One's Sense Of Place?mentioning

confidence: 99%

Approaches to sustaining people–place bonds in conservation planning: from value-based, living heritage, to the glocal community

Chen,

Wang

2024

Built Heritage

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This review paper explores approaches to sustaining the enduring connection between communities and heritage places in conservation planning. Amidst global overtourism, the gradual outmigration and sudden displacement of local communities from heritage places disrupt not only physical ties between people and places but also shared traditions, memories and emotional bonds. These intangible qualities constitute the social dimension of heritage and are pivotal to its cultural significance. However, existing conservation approaches to safeguarding this social dimension often rely on the continued presence of local communities, which may yield limited effectiveness in restoring people–place bonds amidst challenges posed by overtourism and displacement. This review unpacks the term ‘social value’ within the framework of value-based assessment and progresses towards a dynamic conception of ‘sense of place’. In response to the changing social composition of ‘local communities’ at heritage places, this review examines approaches for conserving the social dimension of heritage, aiming to sustain the enduring continuity of people–place bonding. It proposes a broader definition of ‘sense of place’ that transcends the preconceived notion of stakeholder groups as a geographically defined community and suggests leveraging digital social platforms to re-establish these bonds. The review concludes by advocating for the ‘glocal community’ approach, acknowledging the personal emotional connections that individuals form with a heritage place regardless of their places of residence. This approach has the potential to complement existing methods, such as value-based assessment and the living heritage approach, which are commonly practised in contemporary conservation efforts.

show abstract

“…A place is a location that relates to relevant context and reflects a symbolic meaning (Jordaan et al, 2008). Therefore, meaningful places often relate to history (Garcia et al, 2018). Tuan (1990) and Stedman (2016) mentioned the importance of meaning in understanding places.…”

Section: Understanding the Perspectives Of Placementioning

confidence: 99%

The Historical Implications of the Keraton Yogyakarta on the Conception of Place in the Jeron Beteng Area, Yogyakarta

Herliana

2024

JRS

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The Sultanate of Yogyakarta has been a distinct part of the characters associated with Yogyakarta City. The Jeron Beteng area, which is administratively located in the District of Kraton, was in the past the center of this Sultanate. It becomes part of historical journeys that construct the identity of Yogyakarta city as a place. Since its confirmed status as a heritage zone, the Jeron Beteng continuously attracts increasing tourists. It becomes subject to continuous land use, traffic, migration, and land ownership changes. As a result, the identity of the place has been transformed unclearly. This study views that, understanding the conception of a Jeron Beteng area as a place is essential to preserve its identity. It explores the dynamics of this conception based on cultural significances derived from historical events between 1755 and the present time. The research question is "How does the existence of the Keraton Yogyakarta affect the concept of place of the Jeron Beteng Area?" This study uses a historical-comparative method supported by secondary data. Data analysis is based on political, economic, social, and cultural influences on each phase of the Sultan's reign. Study results reveal that political, economic, social, and cultural conditions in each era of the Sultan's reign affect the dynamics of place conception of the Jeron Beteng area.Keywords: the conception of place; Jeron Beteng area; historical events; a cultural value AbstrakKasultanan Yogyakarta telah menjadi bagian khas dari karakter yang diasosiasikan dengan Kota Yogyakarta. Kawasan Jeron Beteng yang secara administatif terletak di Kecamatan Kraton dahulu merupakan pusat kesultanan ini. Kawasan ini menjadi bagian perjalanan sejarah yang membangun identitas Kota Yogyakarta sebagai sebuah tempat. Sejak penunjukannya sebagai cagar budaya, Kawasan Jeron Beteng secara berkelanjutan mengalami peningkatan jumlah kunjungan wisatawan. Kawasan ini telah mengalami perubahan yang terus-menerus dalam alih fungsi lahan, lalu lintas, migrasi, dan kepemilikan lahan. Identitas tempat telah ditransformasi secara tidak jelas. Studi ini memandang jika memahami konsepsi Kawasan Jeron Beteng sebagai sebuah tempat dalam rangka melestarikan identitasnya merupakan hal yang esensial. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk menggali dinamika dari konsepsi ini berdasarkan tata nilai budaya yang diderivasi dari beragam peristiwa sejarah yang terjadi dari tahun 1755 sampai sekarang. Pertanyaan penelitian yang digali adalah “Bagaimana keberadaan Keraton Yogyakarta mempengaruhi konsep tempat dari Kawasan Jeron Beteng?” Penelitian ini menggunakan metode historis-komparatif didukung oleh data sekunder. Analisis data didasarkan pada pengaruh aspek politik, ekonomi, sosial, dan budaya dari setiap era pemerintahan Sultan. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa kondisi politik, ekonomi, sosial dan budaya pada setiap era pemerintahan Sultan mempengaruhi dinamika konsep tempat di kawasan Jeron Beteng.Kata kunci: konsepsi tempat; Kawasan Jeron Beteng; peristiwa-peristiwa sejarah; nilai budaya

show abstract

Place attachment and challenges of historic cities

Cited by 9 publications

References 7 publications

Place Attachment at the Ritual Bakar Tongkang for Heritage Tourism in Bagansiapiapi

Place Attachment at the Ritual Bakar Tongkang for Heritage Tourism in Bagansiapiapi

Approaches to sustaining people–place bonds in conservation planning: from value-based, living heritage, to the glocal community

The Historical Implications of the Keraton Yogyakarta on the Conception of Place in the Jeron Beteng Area, Yogyakarta

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About