The recent report of planar tetracoordinate hydrogen (ptH) in In 4 H + is very intriguing in planar hypercoordinate chemistry. Our high-level CCSD(T) calculations revealed that the proposed D 4h -symmetric ptH In 4 H + is a first-order saddle point with an imaginary frequency in the out-of-plane mode of the hydrogen atom. In fact, at the CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pV5Z/aug-cc-pV5Z-PP level, the C 4v isomer, with the H atom located 0.70 Å above the In 4 plane, is 0.5 kcal/mol more stable than the D 4h isomer. However, given the small perturbation from planarity and essentially barrierless C 4v ↔ D 4h ↔ C 4v transition, the vibrationally averaged structure can still be considered as a planar. Extending our exploration to the In n Tl 4−n H + (n = 0−3) systems, we found all these ptH structures, except for In 2 Tl 2 H + , to be the putative global minimum. The single σ-delocalized interaction between the central hydrogen atom and In n Tl 4−n ligand rings proves pivotal in establishing planarity and aromaticity and conferring substantial stability upon these rule-breaking ptH species.