Plant Species Disjunctions

Chloroplast DNA restriction site variation of ten endonucleases was examined among all ten species or varieties of the eastern Asia–eastern North America disjunct section Rytidospermum of Magnolia. Representatives from seven of the other ten sections of Magnolia and four related genera (Liriodendron, Manglietia, Michelia, and Talauma) were also included in the survey. A cladistic analysis of 200 variable sites using Wagner parsimony yielded 11 equally most parsimonious trees with a consistency index of 0.793 and a retention index of 0.870. The section Rytidospermum is polyphyletic in these trees. Magnolia tripetala from the southeastern U.S. is the only American species that has a sister relationship to the Asian taxa, M. hypoleuca, M. officinalis var. officinalis, M. officinalis var. biloba, and M. rostrata. Other American taxa in the section fall into two lineages, with M. macrophylla var. macrophylla, M. macrophylla var. ashei, and M. macrophylla var. dealbata in one, and M. fraseri var. fraseri and M. fraseri var. pyramidata in the other. They are not related to the Asian species as previously believed. The relationships revealed here are in agreement with morphological, allozymic, and cross compatibility data. These results demonstrate that a robust phylogenetic hypothesis is an important prerequisite for understanding biogeographic patterns.

A chloroplast DNA Phylogenetic study of the eastern Asia‐eastern North America disjunct sectionRytidospermumofMagnolia(Magnoliaceae)

Qiu

Chase

Parks

1995

Molecular divergence in the eastern Asia– eastern North America disjunct section Rytidospermum of Magnolia (Magnoliaceae)

Qiu

Parks

Chase

1995

Molecular divergence in the eastern Asia—eastern North American disjunct section Rytidospermum of Magnolia was investigated by allozyme electrophoresis, chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) restriction site analysis, and gene sequencing. We calculated Nei's genetic identities between two Asian species, M. officinalis var. biloba and M. hypoleuca, and three American species, M. tripetala, M. fraseri var. fraseri, and M. macrophylla var. macrophylla, by using gene frequency data from 17 nuclear‐encoded allozyme loci in 67 populations. We then estimated cpDNA sequence divergence between the five species by examining restriction site variation for ten endonucleases over the entire genome. Finally, nucleotide sequences of the chloroplast gene rbcL were compared between M. hypoleuca, M. tripetala, and M. macrophylla var. macrophylla. All three methods consistently yielded low divergence values between the American species M. tripetala and its Asian sister taxa, M. officinalis var. biloba and M. hypoleuca (Nei's I = 0.712 and 0.809, respectively; D‐cpDNA = 0.083% for both pairs; D‐rbcL = 0.000% between M. tripetala and M. hypoleuca). The other two American species, M. fraseri var. fraseri and M. macrophylla var. macrophylla, neither of which is sister to the Asian taxa, exhibited much higher divergence from the Asian taxa. We interpreted the low divergence between M. tripetala and its Asian sister taxa as a result of recent separation (the late Miocene to early Pliocene), based on time estimates from molecular data as well as geological and paleoclimatic evidence. A comparison of our results with those of the earlier studies revealed a diverse array of levels of divergence between several eastern Asian and eastern North American species pairs. Though different extinction patterns and variation in molecular evolutionary rates may be partly responsible, this heterogeneous pattern of divergence is best explained by different times of disjunction in different taxa, which in turn suggests that the floristic similarity between the two continents was most likely attained by multiple migrations via both Bering and North Atlantic land bridges, or possibly even with involvement of dispersal.

Molecular divergence between disjunct taxa in eastern Asia and eastern North America

Lee

Crawford

et al. 1996

Eastern Asian‐eastern North American disjuncts in four genera were examined for allozyme divergence and sequence divergence of the internal transcribed spacers (ITS) of nuclear ribosomal DNA. The disjunct pairs of taxa include Caulophyllum robustum‐C. thalictroid.es, Menispermum dauricum‐M. canadense, Penthorum chinense‐P. sedoides, and Phryma leptostachya var. asiatica‐P. leptostachya var. leptostachya. Allozyme divergence was comparable in Caulophyllum and Penthorum (genetic identities of 0.534 and 0.546) and was considerably higher than between pairs of taxa in Menispermum (0.273) and Phryma (0.291). Caulophyllum and Penthorum, which have the highest genetic identities at allozyme loci, also have low ITS sequence divergences (1.30 and 1.65%, respectively). Phryma, which has low isozyme identity, also has the highest ITS sequence divergence (4.46%). The two taxa of Menispermum have low ITS sequence divergence (0.93%) despite having a low identity (0.273) at allozyme loci. The results suggest that divergence between the taxa in the four genera are not the result of a single historical event. Estimated divergence times are reasonably consistent with a late Miocene disjunction for Caulophyllum and Penthorum, whereas the age of the Phryma disjunction is calculated at over 20 million years. The nonconcordant divergences between allozymes and ITS sequences in Menispermum may be caused by concerted evolution in the latter or possibly longer generation time in the woody plants. Additional molecular data are needed to clarify the situation.