The establishment of protective forests plays a crucial role in mitigating soil erosion on slopes within hilly and gully regions. However, in practical applications, the configuration of protective forests on slopes is intricate and diverse, and the suitability and rationality of different configuration patterns for various slope sections have not been thoroughly investigated. This study focuses on a 40-year-old artificial protective forest, examining 16 different configuration patterns on the top, middle, and lower slopes. It compares the growth conditions, community structure stability, and characteristics of the saturated soil’s hydraulic conductivity. The findings indicate that the top slope should be identified as a critical area for slope protection. The optimal configuration for this area is the “tree + grass” pattern with a spacing of 5 m × 5 m, which promotes the optimal growth of tree species and effectively reduces the surface runoff of gravel particles ranging from 1 cm to 3 cm in diameter. On the middle slope, the “tree + shrub + grass” structure proves effective in slowing down the erosive force of slope runoff. The recommended spacing for trees is 5 m × 6 m, and for understory shrubs, it is 1 m × 6 m. This configuration pattern results in the most stable structure for the plant community and maximizes the water conservation potential of forest litter. By analyzing the characteristics of the saturated soil’s hydraulic conductivity, we find that the complexity of the plant configuration on the lower slopes is correlated with a greater coefficient of variation in the saturated soil’s hydraulic conductivity. Nevertheless, there is no significant difference in the average soil saturated hydraulic conductivity per unit area between the different configuration patterns. Consequently, the lower slope can rely on the natural recovery of herbaceous plants. The results of this research contribute valuable scientific and technical insights to the management of soil erosion in hilly and gully areas, both in China and around the world.