Coevolution is often defined as reciprocal evolutionary change in interacting species (Janzen, 1980), and specialized antagonistic interactions are expected to show a signature of matching defenceoffence phenotypes as a result of long and intimate coevolutionary histories (Berenbaum, 1983;Brodie et al., 2002). In natural systems, however, community complexity often disrupts such pairwise coevolution, causing deviations from the expectation of phenotype matching (Thompson et al., 2017;Zangerl & Berenbaum, 2003). If plants are attacked by a community of herbivores, the total selective impact of these attackers on defence may be diffuse, making it challenging to decipher coevolutionary dynamics between any one pair of species (