Platforms, politics and precarity: Hong Kong television workers amid the new techno-nationalist media agenda

Abstract

In contrast to the infrastructural properties of Western media platforms aiming at market power expansion, the digital platform model in China is designed and developed with a techno-nationalist media agenda. In the case of Hong Kong, we look into how exactly the platformisation process restructures and interacts with its surrounding cultural, economic, political and social activities. This article contributes to the Creative Labour Studies by analysing the intricate linkages between the city’s unique socio-historical, technological and political trajectories and the lived dynamics of television work. Through in-depth interviews with Hong Kong TV workers, we reinstitute the techno-political to the analytical lens of Creative Labour Studies. We posit that the ebb and flow of Hong Kong’s TV industry and its creative labour process are not just guided by economic considerations under global media platformisation, but also uniquely entangled with its historical legacies, socio-technical contexts, and political and ideological framework. Our empirics show how the conflicting strategies directed by both the platformised business models and an unprecedented techno-nationalist media agenda generate ambiguity and inconsistency in daily TV operations. The elevated self-censorship and loss of editorial autonomy alongside the rapid media platformisation reinforce a normative ‘moralist regime’ creating specific forms of precarity and dissatisfaction among Hong Kong TV workers, undermining the development of the creative industry and a creative career. But the changing techno-political conditions also alter TV workers’ perceived nature, functionality and value of creative work, enacting a self-governed ‘ethical regime’ in their professional practices, and open up new creative opportunities.

“We are snowflakes”: Minor transnationalism and the cultural resilience of slash fanfiction community in China

“…Given this situation, buycott is deemed as a more efficient way than merely condemning the idol and forcing him to respond to the dispute. When overt resistance is discouraged by techno-political circumstances, political dissidence can be reshuffled into an alternative social or cultural identity that functions as a sense-making device for the suppressed group to search for alternative narratives and uphold their resilience through convert counter-practices (Tse & Shum, 2023). The felt powerlessness of slash practitioners is transformed into a shared antagonism towards "the capital" as a powerful player.…”

Debating the “Chineseness” of a mobile game in online communities

“…The cultural industry in Hong Kong illustrates this complicated power relations in flux. With its history as a British colony and the current political context, the juxtaposition of neoliberal market-driven platformization and state-driven techno-nationalism has rendered unique work experiences for television workers (Tse and Shum, 2023). By taking the approach of “China-as-Method,” we contextualize the authenticity debate on Chineseness in the complicated power relations among the West, China, and other Asian and African countries (in this case, Japan in particular).…”

‘Traffic rewards’, ‘algorithmic visibility’, and ‘advertiser satisfaction’: How Chinese short-video platforms cultivate creators in stages

“…Existing studies (Tse and Shum, 2022; Alacovska and Gill, 2019) on creative work on platforms are mainly based on social media in Europe and the United States, such as YouTube and Instagram. They demonstrate the confrontation between self-expression and commercial strategies in creator-platform relationships (O’Meara, 2019).…”