Pleasing the crowd: the determinants of securities crowdfunding success

Abstract

PurposeSince May 2016, small firms have been able to issue debt and equity securities in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Commission's “Regulation Crowdfunding”. This regulation provides unsophisticated investors a chance to participate in the securities markets, and it gives small businesses an opportunity to raise funds. This paper investigates the determinants of crowdfunding success, security design in a crowdfunding setting, the amount of crowdfunding campaign proceeds and campaign duration.Design/methodology/approachThe sample used in this study is based on 750 completed securities crowdfunding offerings that were launched between May 2016 and May 2018. The data on crowdfunding issues were webscraped from Form C filings available through SEC EDGAR filing system. Additional data were hand-collected from a variety of platforms that list and aggregate crowdfunding offerings.FindingsWe show that relatively larger and more profitable companies have a better chance to achieve crowdfunding success. We find that the issuance of equity results in a lower probability of success compared to issuing debt. In addition, the issuance of equity is negatively correlated with the amount of proceeds from a crowdfunding campaign. A novel finding is that a choice of a funding instrument has a negligible impact on the amount of proceeds. This finding, combined with reduced probability of success for equity issuers, can be interpreted as a signal to rely more on debt and convertibles when designing crowdfunding campaigns.Research limitations/implicationsOrganized under “Regulation Crowdfunding,” the US securities-based crowdfunding market has been operating for several years. Relative to other securities markets it is still considered to be in its infancy. Given a relatively small data sample, the results have to be interpreted with caution.Practical implicationsThe paper shows that small businesses and unsophisticated investors can benefit from securities-based crowdfunding, which is subject to oversight of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Although the mission of the regulator is to protect investors, the SEC took on a rather relaxed approach in regulating types of instruments used in crowdfunding. Our paper shows that equities, including “Simple Agreements For Future Equity” (SAFEs) might not be the best choice for crowdfunding success. This sentiment is mirrored in law literature which considers securities known as SAFEs more suitable for venture capital campaigns rather than for crowdfunding.Originality/valueThe paper adds value to the novel field of securities-based crowdfunding by testing several hypotheses on the crowdfunding success, the amount of proceeds and campaign duration.

The Drivers of Successful Crowdfunding Projects in Africa during the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…The digital evolution and innovation in crowdfunding have emerged as an alternative access to finance for entrepreneurs, which has dramatically grown in recent times (Shneor and Vik 2020). Invariably, the studies that have examined the factors influencing crowdfunding campaigns with a focus on equity-based and rewardbased crowdfunding campaigns have mainly focused on developed countries (Petitjean 2018;Sajjan and Venkatesha 2020;Liu et al 2022;Smirnova et al 2019). Hence, the current study contributes to the gap in knowledge in this regard by focusing on Africa.…”

Ensuring Investor Security and the Future of Crowdfunding: Exploring Legal Protection and Innovations in Indonesia

“…2.5 billion during of license utilization. This assets prerequisite comprises core savings, compulsory savings, reserved funds, and grants, all in accordance with the provisions of cooperative legislation [10].…”

Sharia External Financing Alternatives for Business Expansion Study Case: PT. XYZ

“…It involves investors, entrepreneurs (borrowers), and operators who manage repayment and act as intermediaries 6 . In Securities Crowdfunding debt or equity issuance can be utilized 7 . Islamic Securities Crowdfunding (I-SCF) employs stock or Sukuk as financial instruments.…”