Poles Apart? EU Enlargement and the Labour Market Outcomes of Immigrants in the United Kingdom

Abstract

The United Kingdom was one of only three countries to allow migrants from accession countries to enter their labour markets more or less without restriction following European Union enlargement in May 2004. Therefore, it is important to establish the characteristics and labour market performance of migrants from these countries who have subsequently entered the United Kingdom. We principally analyse Labour Force Survey data to compare the labour market outcomes of recent migrants from Poland and other accession countries to those of earlier migrant cohorts from these countries as well as to those of other recent migrants to the United Kingdom. We find that the majority of post-enlargement migrants from the new member states have found employment in low paying jobs, despite some (especially Poles) possessing relatively high levels of education. It follows that recent Polish migrants typically have lower returns to their education than other recent arrivals. Migrants from the new member states who arrived immediately prior to enlargement have similar characteristics and labour market outcomes, apart from displaying a higher propensity to be self-employed. These results are discussed in the context of policy changes, migration strategies, assimilation effects and possible impacts on the sending countries.

Mobility in Transition : Migration Patterns after EU Enlargement

“…This reality can be directly linked to multiple other aspects of migrant profiles, such as education and earnings. Drinkwater, Eade and Garapich (2009) show that recent migrants from A-8 countries, for example, experience the lowest earning returns to their education, which is consistent with findings that well-qualified workers from these countries often work in low-skilled occupations.…”

Adapting chain referral methods to sample new migrants

“…A common comment, however, was that new migrants were likely to be very busy, stemming from the fact that they would be setting up house and adjusting to a new linguistic, institutional, and social context. In addition, many were working long hours as target earners in low-wage jobs (Anderson et al 2006;Drinkwater, Eade, and Garapich 2009). Such low-wage long-hours work has been suggested to be a particular feature of the employment of newly arrived or temporary migrants as they accumulate resources and before they make the transition to jobs more in line with their qualifications (Parutis 2014).…”

Pitfalls of immigrant inclusion into the European welfare state

“…Barrett and McCarthy, 2008;Drinkwater, Eade and Garapich, 2009). The study by Riphahn (2004) on German guest workers, for example, suggests that the state's early immigration policy, which primarily attracted low-skilled workers, is essentially linked to higher use of welfare benefits by immigrants than natives.…”