Police Perspectives on Road Safety and Transport Politics in Germany

Abstract

Road safety is a key concern of transport governance. In the European Union, a Road Safety Programme was adopted in 2011, with the objective to reduce road deaths in Europe by 50% in the period from 2011 to 2020. Evidence suggests, however, that this goal will not be met. Against this background, this paper investigates police perspectives on traffic laws, traffic behaviour, and transport policy. Police officers working with road safety are in a unique position to evaluate and judge the efficiency of road safety policies, as they record traffic offences, fine, investigate, and witness in court. Geographically, focus is on transport policy in Germany, a country with a dense road network, high levels of car ownership, and a large number of car manufacturers. A total of 14 semi-structured interviews were carried out with police officers in a wide variety of positions within the traffic police in Freiburg. Thematic analysis is used to analyse content and to identify aspects that represent major areas of concern. Officers affirm that traffic laws question traffic safety, for instance with regard to speed and speed limits, or elderly drivers. Specific recommendations for changes in transport policies are made, and results are discussed in the context of their implications for road safety and the European Union's Road Safety Programme.

Barriers to Implementing Pro-Cycling Policies: A Case Study of Hamburg

“…However, it is in accordance with British findings that the adoption and implementation of pro-cycling policies could be influenced by various stakeholders [42,45], for example, car lobby groups, shop owners, and residents. The influence of car lobby groups on transport policy echoes a case study in Freiburg where car lobby groups tend to be against the speed and emission limits [17]. The individual level barriers that emerged (safety concern, impractical, and subcultural for commuting) were in accordance with a number of studies [20][21][22][23]25].…”

“…However, cycling promotion in big cities in Germany is challenging. First, Germany has a high level of car ownership and a sufficient and high-quality road infrastructure supply that can facilitate convenient car use [15][16][17]. The passenger car is the major mode of commuting for employees (67.7% in 2016) [18].…”

Causes and Health-Related Outcomes of Road Traffic Crashes in the United Arab Emirates: Panel Data Analysis of Traffic Fines

“…Carnis and Blais demonstrated that according to the installation of fixed and mobile cameras in France the fatality rate decreased by more than 20% and non-fatal traffic injuries were reduced from 26% in 2002 to just less than 1% in 2010 (Carnis & Blais, 2013). This helps the European Union towards its ambitious goal of a 50% reduction in road deaths by 2020 (Gössling, 2017) based on improved law enforcement strategies to prevent excessive speeding and reduce drinking and driving (ICF Consulting, 2003). These law enforcement strategies are also applicable in the UAE to reduce the RTI burden, including a national alcohol abuse registry (Osman et al, 2015).…”

The relationship between illnesses and medical drug consumption with the occurrence of traffic accidents among truck and bus drivers in Tehran, Iran

“…4 Studies revealed that young people aged 15–30 years were affected most by driving accidents, and less experienced drivers were involved in more serious accidents, which lead to death. 5 , 6 , 7 …”